|
|
ATTORNEY [ licensed to practice in KOREA, U.S.A., ILLINOIS ] LEE, JAE WOOK
∗ [LANGUAGE Translation] You can use Google Translate application to see in your own language the pages in this website. For your convenience, click the "Google Translate(Select Language)" |
FEE Ұ |
| |
λ |
| |
TAX |
| |
뵿 |
| |
|
| |
Ư PAT ǥ |
| |
Ѽ |
| |
ART |
| |
|
| |
|
| |
USA ̹ VISA |
| |
ȥ |
| |
Foreign Clients |
| | | |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Start →Ƿ ؼ - ٰŰ ִ ؼ 2009. 9. 14. 溯ȣȸ μҼ ̳ ڷ Ƿʺм: ߽Ρ ․ . Ȳʱ 1 ѱ Ȳ α̻ȸ(Human Rights Council) 2008 6 12 ä HRC, Outcome of the universal periodic review: Republic of Korea, UN Doc. A/HRC/DEC/8/123, 12 June 2008. αǻȲ ѱο 1951 1967 ϰ, ι ϵ ϶ ǰ Ͽ. HRC, Report of the Working Group on the Universal Periodic Review: Republic of Korea, UN Doc. A/HRC/8/40, 29 May 2008, para. 64.30. öȸ(Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination) 2007 8 17 ѱ κ ؿ ΰ Ͽ û ǻ ȭ Ͽ ȿ ѵ ûڵ鸸 ް ִ. ǥϰ, ΰ νûڿ ѱ Ÿ ε ص鿡 Ǿ Ѵ. 鼭 Ư ϰ żϰ ̷ϰ, νûڿ ε ȣ ο ־ϸ, ѱȸ ε Ű ġ äõǾ Ѵ. ǰϰ ִ. CERD, Concluding observations of the Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination: Republic of Korea, UN Doc. CERD/C/KOR/CO/14, 17 August 2007, para. 10 ټ ѱ õ 巯ְ ִ. 1992 12 ѱ 1951 (the 1951 Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees) 1967 (the 1967 Protocol Relating to the Status of Refugees) Ͽ, 1993 12 Ա װ żϿ, 1994 7 Ա ȿǾ 1994 ó νû ϰ Ǿ. DZ 2000 ѱ αⱸ ȸ ̴. 1994 2008 12 31 15Ⱓ ü νûڴ 2,168 Ұ, ü νû 50.5% 1,286 ɻ ̰, ɻ簡 879 101, ġȲ ε ü 㰡 71̴. ü û 4.7% ſ ִ. Ա․ܱå, Ա․ܱå 2008 12ȣ(2009. 1.), p.35. ó νû Ѽ, Ȳ, ΰ õ ü ɰ 巯ְ ִ. 2 Ȳ ʿ μ DZ Ѵ. μ ǰ ϴ ƴ϶, μ ϴ ̴. װ ޱ Ǵ ƴ϶, ̱ Ǵ ̴. UNHCR 28; ̻ȸĢ 2004/83/EC (14) Ȯϰ ִ. ǰ鵵 â ƴϹǷ ϸ 翬 ο شѴ ̶͡ ϸ鼭 ݰ Ͽ ǽϿ Դ. 2007. 6. 27. 200621643 ǰ; 2001. 8. 16. 991990 ǰ; 2009. 4. 30. 200844228 ǰ . ü౹ Ͽ ο Ͽ ̸ Ƶ鿩 ȣ οϵ ǹ ƴϸ( 12 1ȣ ), ο ȣ ο , οѴٸ δ Ϲ ü౹ ֱ صǰ ִ. , Ա 762 1 ܱκ û ִ ܱ ִٰ ϰ Ǵ ο οǴ Ͽ ƹ ΰ , ̴ Ͽ ش ܱο üڰ οϴ ȣ 翬 ԵǾ ִ ؼ ϴ ̰, ǰ ܼ ûڰ ߾ Ȯϴ ǹ̿ ġ ( κп ǰ 緮 ), ܱο Ǹ οϴ μ ̿ Ͽ ǰ 緮 ο ƾ ̴. ǰ ܱο û μ ߾ θ Ȯ , Ǵ 쿡 ̸ ʷ Ա 762 1 Ͽ üڰ ο ȣ ο , ƴϸ ʿ ұϰ 3 ŽŰų ȣ ¸ ο 緮 Ͽ Ѵ( Ǵ ִ ߹ϰų ȯϴ 33 1ȣ Ͽ ǰ ִ). Ա 緮 ǴϿ νû 켱 μ ߾ θ ǴϿ ش缺 , ο ش ȣ ο ο Ͽ 緮 Ͽ Ѵٰ Ǵϰ ִ. , Ա ش缺θ Ǵϰ , ȣοʿ伺 θ Ǵϴ 2ܰ ľ ϴ Ǯϰ ִ. ̷ 2ܰ Ǵܱؿ Ͽ "緮 翡 ռ ߾ ο ʿ 緮 縦 ó Ͽ Ҹ Ѵ." ϰ ִ. ̴ 1ܰ Ǵؾ ϴ ش缺 ο Ͽ ߸ ǴϿ ο شԿ ұϰ ش缺 ȣο 緮 ʾ ϴٰ Ǵ ̴. ü ο ǰῡ ü Ǹ 쿡 Ͽ Ǿ Ѵ١ ôϸ鼭 ̰ ο ü ⺸ٴ ȣ ο ϴ١ ǽϿ ġ ü 簡 ȣ ο ϴ ִ ϰ ִ. 2006. 5. 10. 200519643 ǰ. ̷ Ƿ µ ұϰ ǵ ǿ ϸ鼭 ȣ ο Ǵ Ƿʴ . ̴ ΰ Կ ־ ̸ ϴ 쿡 ǿ شѴٴ ϰ ְ, ̸ ϴ 쿡 ǿ ش ʴ´ٴ ־ ȣ ο ΰ Ǵ ʰ ̶ ִ. ٸ μ ü 緮 ٶν ܱ , ߽ Ա å , Ư ̵ ֹο öϰ ν γ Ǵܿ ־ ߿ ϰ ۿ ִ ϰ ִٴ ϴ. ̷ Ƿ µ ǹ Ϲݰ ؼ ϰ ִٰ Ǵܵȴ. μ, ' ¿ ̳ й', 溯ȣȸ, ¿ ̳(2008. 7. 15.), pp.80-83; ö, '2007 κо α ', ֻȸ ȣ , 2007 ѱαǺ(2008. 1.), p.449; Ȳʱ, ' ', Ѻȣȸ, 2007 αǺ(2008. 3.), pp.544-545 . 켱, 6 1 Ͽ ü, μ ȿ¡ . ǼҴ ̿ Ͽ 6 1 Ǵ 츮 Ϲ ε ȿ ٴ ͡ Ǽ 2001. 4. 26. 99尡13 . ̶ Ͽ ǹ̸ Ȯϰ ִ. 2 Ͽ Ͽ ܱΡ 塯ȴ. ̴ ױ ȭ η ̹ ǥϰ ִ ȭ ·μ Ͽ ּ ܱ Ȯ ؿ Ͽ ܱ ȣϰڴٴ ִ صǰ ִ. Ǽ 1991. 7. 22. 89尡106 , Ǽ 2001. 4. 26. 99尡13 . , ϰ ѹα μ ȿ 뿡 Ͽ ȴٰ ϰڴ. °, ǰ 12 1ȣ ٰŷ ̶ ϴ ȣ ο ο ȣ ο ü౹ ֱ μ ǰ Ȥ 緮 οȴٰ ǽϰ ִ. , Ͽٴ ǹ̴ ̸ ȿ Թ ϰ ο ȣ ο ǹ Ƶ鿴ٴ ̴. 12 1ȣ Ͽ ּ Ȥ ż ϵ Ǿִ Ϲ ƴ϶ , ģ źл ǹϴ μ Ǹɷ, ȥδɷ, , ӱ Ѵ. Nehemiah Robinson, Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees: Its History, Contents and Interpretation(Institute of Jewish Affairs, 1953), p.24; Guy S. Goodwin-Gill and Jane McAdam, The Refugee in International Law, 3rd Ed.(Oxford, 2007), p.527; Hathaway, James C., The Rights of Refugees under International Law(Cambridge, 2005), p.209; źС ϵ ǰ . ٸ 쿡 װ ɷ( ñ, ̼ Ǹ, ȥδɷ, ȥ ɷ, ɷ (İ) Ѵ. Ծ, , ȥ, ȥ, ģ, Ǹ ϲ ȴ. Paul Weis, The Refugee Convention, 1951: The Travaux Preparatoires Analysed(Cambridge University Press, 1995), p.107. ̴ ϴ Ǹ, Ư ȥο ϴ Ǹ 2ȣ , 13, 14, 15, 16, 3, ȸ 4 뿡 ߾ ϴ. 12 1ȣ ٰŷ ο ȣ ο ־ 緮 ϴ 뿡 ؼ ۿ . °, ǰ Ա Ͽ ϰ ƴ ؼ üڰ οϴ ȣ 翬 ԵǾ ִ ؼϿ ϱ Ա Ȯϴ Ͱ Ǵ ϹǷ 緮 οǾ ִٰ ƾ Ѵٰ ǽϰ ִ. Ǹ ϰ ִ ƴ϶ ٿ Ǹ ü ϰ ְ ̵ ȿ¡ Ƿ Ա ٰ Ͽ ̸ ϰ ƴϴٰ Ǵ ̴. ٸ Ǵ Ǹ üȭŰ Ǹ ġǴ Ź켱 Ģ̳ Ư켱 Ģ ϴ ´. Ǹ ٰ Ǵϴ ü౹ ƴϴ Ϻ ִ¹ ѹα ̷ ȣ 7 2ȣ 7 1ȣ Ͽ ִ. Ȯ ϰ Ͽ 緮 οǾ ִٰ ϴ ٰŰ Ǵ ۿ ִ. °, ǰ ߾ ϴ Ա 762 1 Ͽ üڰ ο ȣ ο 緮̸, ̶ ϴ 3 ų ȣ ϴٰ ǽϰ ִ. ̴ Ӹ ƴ϶ ϴ ȿ ϴ 6 ݵǴ Ǵ̴. ü౹ ̻ û ִ 쿡 ɻ縦 ź Ͽ DZ⸸ ϸ Ÿ ɿ ǹ Ѵٰ ƾ Ѵ. ټ°, Ա 762 1 ִ. Ͽ ó(Ư ȣ ο) ǻ 緮 , ̴ ȭο ؼ Ÿϸ, ٸ ѱ ȣؾ ǹ Ȯϰ Ѵٴ ǹ̿ Ͽ Ѵ. Ͽ ٲٴ ؾ ʿ䰡 ִ. ̷ ؿ Ͽ, ִ ü ܰ а νŰ ְ ε鿡 ֿ ȸ ͵ üڰݰ εǾ ִµ, ѱ ûϴ ܱ κ üڰ μ ̵ û ٷ Ⱓ üڰ ο ǹ ȣ ϴ μ, ȣ ομ 緮 ϴ ̷ ǹ ȣ ǹ Ȯ ʾҴٴ Ѵٰ ϸ鼭 µ ϴ ذ ִ. 輺, ' ¿ ̳ й', 溯ȣȸ, ¿ ̳(2008. 7. 15.), pp.92-93. , ȣ Ͽ ٽ ƾ κ ȯ Ģ̴. ̿ ٰϿ ü౹ ϰ, ο ؼ װ ظ ɼ ִ ǹ ȴ. ̷ ǹ ǹ̴ ε û ӹ ִ Ǹ γ ް ȴٴ ̴. ؾ ȣ ο ִٴ DZ ƴ. , ܼ ü(simple presence), ü(legal presence) Ǵ (legal residence) ٸ Ǹ Ǵ ü ȣ ο 緮 ǹ̰ ƴ϶ ̶ Ͽ Ǿ ο ٸ ó Ȥ ȣ ִٴ ǹ̸, Ͽ 쿡 ȣ ƾ Ѵٴ Ÿְ ִٰ ְ, James C. Hathaway, The Rights of Refugees under International Law(Cambridge, 2005), pp.156-160 . ȣ 뵵 ü ڰ ־ٴ ̻ ǹ̸ ϴ 巯ְ ִ. Alice Edwards, Human Rights, Refugees, and the Right To Enjoy Asylum, International Journal of Refugee Law, vol. 17, no. 2 (2005), pp.302-303. ش αǼ(Universal Declaration of Human Rights) 14 1 ٸ طκ ȣ ϰ Ǹ ϿǷ ȣ ο ǹ δ ȣ ο Ǹ ؼ ɼ ִٰ Ѵ. Niraj Nathawani, Rethinking Refugee Law (Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 2003), p.131. ̴ ӷ ִ 1966 ù ġ Ǹ Ծ(International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights) Ե Ͽ, 1969 ȸ ȣ (Declaration on Territorial Asylum) ұϰ ȣ (Convention on Territorial Asylum) üϷ 1977 õ ȸ Ǹμ Ƶ鿩 Ѱ踦 Ȯνְ ִٰ Ѵ. 輺, ' ¿ ̳ й', 溯ȣȸ, ¿ ̳(2008. 7. 15.), pp.93-94. ο ȸ Ϲ Ǵ ȣ ʴ´ٴ Ϲ ̴. Sam Blay and Andreas Zimmermann, 'Recent Changes in German Refugee Law: A Critical Assessment', American Journal of International Law, vol. 88, no. 2 (April 1994), p362. , Ϲ ȣο ǹ ϴ° ǹ ° Sylvie Da Lomba, The Right to Seek Asylum Status in the European Union(Intersentia, 2004), pp.8-9. ش ڸ ȥϿ ǻ Ͻϴ 弱 Ǹ ϰ ִ. αǼ ȣ Ǹ ϰ ȣ ο ǹ ʾҴٴ ̸, 籹 Ǵ ο Ͽ οϿ ǹ , 鿡 Ϲ ȣ ο ǹ ϴ ƴϴ. Ư ȣ ǹ̰ ֱ οѴٴ ǹ̶ ̸ ο ǹ ִٰ . Geoff Gilbert, 'Is Europe Living Up to Its Obligations to Refugees?', European Journal of International Law, vol. 15, no. 5 (2004), p.965 ȣ ǵ ᱹ ̷ ǹ Ϲȭϱ õ з ư ǹ ̰, ȿ ѱ ѱ ٰ ӷ ִ ǹ δϴ Ͱ ٸ ̴. Guy S. Goodwin-Gill and Jane McAdam, The Refugee in International Law, 3rd Ed.(Oxford, 2007), pp.358-365 . ڱ üϴ ο Ͽ ٰϿ ȯ Ģ ϴ ü ȣ οϴ ؼϴ ´ٰ ƾ Ѵ. Gina Clayton, Textbook on Immigration and Asylum Law, 5th Ed. (Oxford University Press, 2004), p.346; James A. Sweeney, 'The Lure of 'Facts' in Asylum Appeals: Critiquing the Practice of Judges', Steven R. Smith, (ed.), Applying Theory to Policy and Practice: Issues for Critical Reflection(Ashgate, 2007), p.21. ִ ȯ ʰ ü ڰ ־ٴ ٷ ȣ ٽ̱ ̴. ֱ ϱ Ƿʵ ټ ٸ ǥ ϰ ִ. Ա 2 22ȣ, 762 1, 1, 1 Ͽ , û ִ ϴ Ͽ Ѵ. ǽϿ ϰ ִ. 2008. 7. 24. 200719539 ǰ; 2009. 7. 15. 2009331 ǰ . ̷ ǽð ش缺 Ǵܰ ȣοʿ伺 Ǵ 2ܰ 䱸ϴ ϱ Ƿʵ 弱 ̷ ̶ ش缺 Ǵ Ϳ ҰϹǷ Ƿʵ Ͽ ο ٰ ִ. δ Ƿʵ ǿ ƴ϶ ؼ ӿ ̷ ǽö Ƿʵ ߸ Ǹ ϴ ǹ̸ ְڴ. ̷ ǰṮ ߴٴ ߾ ڷ ؼ , ǽ ü ڷ ؼ , ڷ ؼDZ ؼ ϱ Ƿʵ ֵ Ȯ Ͽ ϸ, ǰ Ŀ ϱ ǰῡ ǽø ״ ݺϰ ִ 2008. 9. 25. 200731911 ǰ; 2009. 4. 30. 200844228 ǰ . 忡 ȭ ִٰ Ǵϴ ִٰ ϰڴ. 3 Ǵܱ ٰŰ ִ Ͽ ϰǰ νû ְ ɸ° Ȳ Ͽ ħǾ Ͽ Դ. DZ ؼ û ؿ δ ϰ ٰŸ 䱸Ѵ. ̴ û ְ ɸ° Ȳ Ͽ ħǾ ǹϴµ , ո ûο ־ Ͱ ü Ȳ ӿ ̴ ؿ Ǵܵȴٸ ٰŸ ϴ. ûο ־ ü Ȳ ǴԿ û ϴ Ϲ αǻȲ Ͽ , ư û Ϲ Ȳ ü ӿ ûο ɼ ִ Ͽ Ǿ (). 2007. 6. 27. 200621643 ǰ; 2001. 8. 16 991990 ǰ. ֱ ϱ Ͽ ٰŰ ִ Ͽ Ǵ ذ Ģ ϰ ִ. Ǵ ء , ü Ǵ Ͽ ΰ ߴ ħس ߱ϴ ̰, ظ ٰ ִ û ϴ ܱ Ͽ ̳, Ư Ͽ ܱο ſ Ͽ ü ϵ 䱸 ϰ ְ, Ա , Ա νû Ⱓ, û , Ȳ, ְ , ûڰ ϴ ġ․ȸ․ȭ ȯ, Ȳ ߾ ü ź Ͽ ϴ ո 쿡 ִٰ ̴. 2008. 7. 24. 200719539 ǰ; 2009. 5. 15. 200844259 ǰ . Ƿʰ ٰŰ ִ 信 Ǹ νû ְ ɸ° Ȳ Ͽ ħǾ Ѵٰ ǽϰ ְ, Ǵ ٰŷμ ְ ûڰ ְ ûڰ ϴ Ȳ ְ, ҷμ û Ա Ρ, Ա νû Ⱓ, û , Ȳ, ûڰ ϴ ġ․ȸ․ȭ ȯ桯 ִ Ϳ ߾ ․ Ҹ ϴ ϰ ִٰ ִ. Ƿʰ ϰ ִ Ȳ ûڰ ϴ ġ․ȸ․ȭ ȯ桯 ٸ ҵ ؿ Ͽ õǾ, κȣ ǹ̸ Һиϴ. Աϸ鼭 νû ʴ ԱΡ, νû Ͽ ϰ ϱ ư, Ա Ρ, Ա νû Ⱓ, û Ϲ νûڰ ѱ Ͽ ٷ û ʴ Ҹϰ ۿ ɼ . , ǹ̡ й, б αǹ, - ǡ(2009. 4. 14.), pp.88-89. ־ ļϴ ٿ ̵ ҵ νû ٰŰ ִ ϴ ҷ ۿϰ ִ. ̷ ҵ ־ Ͽ ϰ, ̸ 쿡 װ ǹ̿ Ͽ Ȯ ʿ䰡 ִ ̴. ְ ҿ ؼ Ƿʿ ̸ ϰ ʴ ãƺ Ա Ⱑ Ȱ ̶ų νû Ⱑ ü ϱ ̶ ôϱ ־ û , ְ Ҹ Ǵϰ ִ. ٰŰ ִ ְ ҿ Ῡ ο νû ǽû, Ҽ ̸ κ , ڰ ʴ , Ģμ ְ ҿ ϸ鼭 δ Ȥ ɼ̶ Ҹ ִ ƴѰϴ ǹ ۿ δ. ٸ Ϻ Ƿʴ б Ͽ ɷµ Ȳ ϸ Ϻ Һиϰų ִ ̸ Ҹ 縦 ϱ ư, ư ؿ ν ٸ ɼ 2008. 5. 2. 200724746 ǰ. ǰ 2008. 11. 25. 200813776 ǰῡ ҵǾ. ǽø ְ Ҹ ϸ鼭 ְ Ұ ϴٰ ϴ Ұ õǸ ٰŰ ִ ִٴ ϰ ִ. ֱ ǰ ߿ ְ ϴ ϴ ǰ ־ Ƿ ָ ʿ䰡 ִٰ Ǵܵȴ. Ȱ Ⱓ ª Ȱ Ͽٰ ε () ηκ ٸ ź̳ ø ƴϿٰ ϳ, ظ ִٴ ٰŰ ִ ְ μ( 37 ), ̷ Ǵ ݵ û ڽ 迡 ٰ ʿ , ģ, Ǵ Ǵ ȸ ٸ 鿡 Ͼ , û ڰ ̶ ٰŰ ִ ϴ Ǵ ε( 43 ), () ΰ ۡ鿡 Ͽ źå ϰ ְ θ ̷ ȯǰų Ͽ ̻, ڽ () ȯ ظ ̶ Ϳ ٰŰ ִ. 209. 1. 8. 200813608 ǰ. 4 å ٰŰ ִ åӰ ؼ ϰǰ å ϴ ִٰ ̳, ݻ ̳ ɼ, ο ڷḦ ϴ Ϲ̶ ̹Ƿ, ־ ο ڷῡ Ͽ ü ϵ 䱸 ü ź ȴ , ̸ ؼ üμ ϰ ߾ ϰ Ϲ ˷ ִ ǰ ݵǾ ȴ. 2007. 6. 27. 200621643 ǰ; 2001. 8. 16. 991990 ǰ. Ͽ Ư ϰ ִ. ֱ åӰ Ͽ û ŷڼ ִ Ǹ, 忡 ϴ , Ű ûڿ ؼ (benefit of the doubt) οϿ Ѵ. Ͽ ʾҴ ؼ ͺο" Ģ ǰῡ ü ϰ ִ. 2008. 2. 20. 200722115 ǰ. ϰ ü ϱ⺸ٴ û̳ شڵ ؼ ⺻ ŷڼ ǹ ٶ ǽø ϱ Ѵ. 2008. 11. 19. 200811497 ǰ. ó Ҹ ǰ κе νû Ȱ̳ 忡 Ͽ ̸ ϰ ʰ, 弭, ǰ ⡻(κȣƮũ , 2007. 9), p.6. ظ 䱸ϴ 2009. 1. 13. 200821591 ǰ. δ ټ å 䱸ϰ ִ. νûڿ ذɼ Ǵ ɼ(50%̻ ɼ)' غٵ ո ɼ(10%̻ ɼ)' ϴ ȣ ϰ Ƿ̸, ؼϴ ؼ Ģ ϹǷ ܼ Ư ϴ ϰ Ȯ ġ ǰ ڸ ٶ ʷ 輺 ٺϹǷ, ϹݼҼ ü ̰ ִ ü ް Ư Ģ Ȯ ʿϴٰ ϰڴ. Ȳʱ, ' ', Ѻȣȸ, 2007 αǺ(2008. 3.), 14, p.550. 5 縦 ϴ ٰŵ 1 Ƿ Ϲ νûڿ μ ִµ ̷ ũ ϴ , ְ ϴ , ź ü ϴ ũ ִ. ٸ ü ․ Ҹ ϴ ü ϳ ⺻ ․ Ұ Բ ǰ ִٰ ƾ ϰ ̵ ϰ зϴ ִٰ ϰڴ. Ƿʴ Ȳ νûڰ ϴ ذ ɼ , ظ , ذ ʰų, 2007. 9. 4. 20071912 ǰ; 2001. 8. 16. 991990 ǰ . ظ Ű , 2007. 12. 26. 20078256 ǰ . ü ζ Ű ų 2008. 7. 3. 2008725 ǰ; 2007. 11. 30. 200726615 ǰ. û̳ ظ ̿ ̶ ϱ , 2008. 11. 11. 2008732 ǰ; 2007. 12. 6. 200727250 ǰ . ظ ظ ذ κ ؼҵǾų ؼҵ ִ , 2007. 6. 8. 200626233 ǰ . , 2007. 6. 27. 200621643 ǰ; 2001. 8. 16. 991990 ǰ . Ȯϰų ü Ῡ, 2008. 1. 24. 200717092 ǰ; 2001. 8. 16. 991990 ǰ . ܼ ҹ ܱ ü Ȥ û, 2001. 8. 16. 991990 ǰ . ű Ȥ ̻ , 2007. 6. 27. 200621643 ǰ; 2003. 12. 23. 200223632 ǰ . ѱ Ա, ü Ȥ ѱ ü νû , 2008. 11. 11. 20085720, 20085737(), 20085744(), 20085751(), 20085768() ǰ; 2008. 6. 13. 200868 ǰ . Ȱ, Ȱ Ա ѱԱ, 2007. 9. 4. 20071912 ǰ; 2003. 12. 23. 200223632 ǰ . ѱ Ȱ νû( ֹο Ұϴٰ ), 2008. 7. 24. 200719539 ǰ; 2007. 6. 27. 200621643 ǰ; 2006. 8. 24. 20069320 ǰ . νû (Ա Ⱓ ϰ üⰣ Ȥ Ŀ ܼ ȭ Ȳ û, 2008. 7. 3. 2008725 ǰ; 2003. 12. 23. 200223632 ǰ . û ü ̳ , Ȥ ü ̳ , Ǵ νû 2008. 11. 11. 20083526 ǰ; 2007. 11. 27. 20075837 ǰ . Ȥ ҹüڷ ܼӵ νû 2007. 9. 4. 20071912 ǰ; 2003. 12. 23. 200223632 ǰ . ), Ա Ȥ Ա ѱ Ȱ ų ұ Ȱ Ұ , 2008. 7. 24. 20081344 ǰ; 2007. 5. 25. 200620022 ǰ; 2006. 2. 3. 200520993 ǰ . Ƿ 巯ų νûϿ ϰų Ŀ Ȱ ϴ ٰŷ Ȱ , 2007. 9. 4. 20071912 ǰ; 2006. 11. 28. 200623531 ǰ . ҼӴü ֿ 2008. 8. 21. 2008503 ǰ; 2007. 10. 5. 200625209 ǰ . Ȥ û Ȥ , 2007. 9. 19. 20074355 ǰ; 2008. 1. 9. 20078768 ǰ . ¡ źϰų ݱ ȸ Ϲκ ȭ ߵ ƴ Ϲ , 2007. 12. 26. 20078256 ǰ . Ȥ ؿ شϴ ߴ αħ , 2008. 11. 25. 200813776 ǰ; 2007. 10. 17. 200710075 ǰ . ѱ Ա ȹ 2008. 6. 13. 200868 ǰ. Ȥ ƴ ѹα ۿ ̺, 2007. 9. 19. 20074355 ǰ; 2007. 6. 8. 200626233 ǰ . ⱹ ÿ νû , 2008. 7. 24. 20081344 ǰ; 2007. 6. 27. 200621643 ǰ; 2006. 11. 28. 200623531 ǰ ȣ(Internal Protection Alternative) ǽ , 2008. 4. 11. 200731836 ǰ . Ȯ ϰų ˷ ǰ ٸ , 2008. 7. 3. 2008725 ǰ; 2003. 12. 23. 200223632 ǰ . ź ٴ 2008. 7. 24. 20081344 ǰ; 2007. 9. 19. 20074355 ǰ; 2001. 8. 16. 991990 ǰ . ٰŷ ٰŰ ִ 縦 ϰ , Ư ü ôϴ ٰŷ δü Ἲ Ե νû ñ, νû Ȱ ٰŷ ִ. 弭, ǰ ⡻(κȣƮũ , 2007. 9), p.6 ̷ Ǵ õ Ȯ ΰ ִ ֱ , Ǵܿ ־ ǿ š Ͽ ϰ, ûڰ ȣ ġ 족 ִٴ Ǵܿ 翬 ʾƾ ϱ Ǵϴ ü ̰ ְ ǴܿҰ Ե ƴϿ Ѵ UNHCR 202 . Ģ ġ ٺϴ. 2 ü Ρ(refugee sur place) ǡ(good faith) DZ Ͽ ۿ ־ ϴ , ݵ νûڰ ҹ ϰ, Ǵ ٰŰ ִ ǹϴ ƴϸ, UNHCR 94 . ̹ ΰ ϰų Ǵ ֱ ġ ǰ ǥϴ Ͱ ڽ ൿ μ ֱ ü ߿ ִ. Vigdis Vevstad, Refugee Protection: A European Challenge(Tano Aschehoug, 1998), pp.53-54; John Vrachnas, Kim Boyd, Mirko Bagaric and Penny Dimopoulos, Migration and Refugee Law: Principles and Practice in Australia, 2nd Ed. (Cambridge University Press, 2008), p.257. ٸ û Ͽ ظ ʷѴٴ ⸦ 캼 ʿ䰡 ְ Ư ൿ 籹 ָ ִ Ǵ ൿ 籹 Ͽ Ǵܵ Ͽ Ѵ(UNHCR 96). 2001 ̷ Ǵ ɼ ݵ κ ⱹ ÿ Ͽ ϴ ƴϴ١ Ͽ ü Ρ ϸ鼭 ûڰ Ͽ ظ ʷѴٴ ⸦ 캼 ʿ䰡 ְ ޱ ϴ 쿡 ȣ ȮǴ ʴ´١ ǽϿ ޱ Ͽ ƴ϶ (good faith) 쿡 Ͽ Ǿ Ѵٴ ִ. 2001. 8. 16. 991990 ǰ; 2003. 12. 23. 200223632 ǰ. ̿ Կ ٸ ƴ϶ ϴ 1 ʴ ϹǷ, ȣޱ ̶ ϴ ɼ ϴ ο شѴ. ǽϿ. 2006. 5. 10. 200519643 ǰ; 2008. 6. 18. 200727242 ǰ. ǰᵵ ֱ ġ ǰ ǥϴ Ͱ ൿ μ ظ ٰŰ մ 쿡 ִ ̰, ȣޱ Ͽٰ Ͽ ƴϴ. ǽϿ ̷ Ȯϰ ִ. 2008. 7. 24. 200719539 ǰ; 2009. 7. 15. 2009331 ǰ. ̿ ǰ νû (good faith) δ ƴ϶ ϰ ִ. ü Ρ νû (good faith) 䱸 Ϻ ڵ ̳ Ϻ ʿ ٰ δ. , ű 籹 ָ Ͽ ʷ , 쿬ϰ Ȥ ڹ νû ϱ 츦 Ͽ, (good faith) ڷ Ρ(bootstrap refugee) David Martin, 'Remarks on Mass Migration of Refugees - Law and Policy', American Society of International Law Proceedings, vol. 76 (1982), p.15. μ 籹 ̵鿡 Ͽ ǹ ٴ ذ װ̴. ̻ȸĢ 2004/83/EC 4 3 (d) ű û Ȱ ȯ ûڸ Ȥ ɰ ؿ ų ΰ ϱ Ͽ Ȱ ȣ û ʿ Ȥ ֵ ٰ Ͽ Ѵٰ ϰ ִ. ̻ȸĢ 5 ü ؿ ٰŰ ִ Ư ű ־ ų̳ ǥ̳ 츦 ϸ鼭, ű û ڽ Ͽ ̷ Ȳ ϴ , Ѽ 鼭 ܼ ޱ , ȸ Ϲ ο ʱ ִٰ ϰ ִ. ̷ 濡 ܱ Ȱ Ȱ ν ű 踦 ʷϴ ϰ ϴ ȣ Ѵٰ ִ. ̴ Ȥ ȣ ο ڸ ̴ ̶ ִٰ ִ. ̹ ȣ 信 ִ ̵ νû ϴ ִ ̴. ܱ ġȰ ȹϴ ϴٸ, ̷ ϰ ̶ ȣ ϴ ִ. Vigdis Vevstad, Refugee Protection: A European Challenge(Tano Aschehoug, 1998), p.53. 켱, ΰ ⺻ Ǹ ǥ , , ΰݱ ܽϴ ش ض ְ ̷ Ȥ νûڵ ǥ չ 縦 ش ϴ ҷ ڸű ִ. James C. Hathaway, The Law of Refugee Status(LexisNexis, 1991), p.37. ٵ δ ǿ νûڰ شǴ° Ͽ ǴܵǾϰ νû ̳ ź, νûڰ ű 쿡 Ǵ ű 籹 µ Ǵ ֿ ӿ ұϰ µ ̷ ⺻ Ǵ ǻ Ͽ Դ. Ϲ ǹ̿ ü (good faith) ִ ٰŸ ã . Guy S. Goodwin-Gill, 'Domain v. Secretary of State for the Home Department - Comment: Refugee Status and 'Good Faith'', International Journal of Refugee Law, vol. 12, no. 4 (2001), pp.670-671. ̰ ǥϿ Ͽ νûڸ ϴ Ͽϰ ִٰ . Vigdis Vevstad, Refugee Protection: A European Challenge(Tano Aschehoug, 1998), p.54. Ӹ ƴ϶ δ (good faith) ̸ܱ Ϲ ȹ ִٴ ϰ , ̴ ǿ ϴ (good faith) νûڳ ġȰ νûڵ ᱹ Ϲ ڽ ִ ٴ ܸϴ ̴. Guy S. Goodwin-Gill and Jane McAdam, The Refugee in International Law, 3rd Ed.(Oxford, 2007), pp.66-67; James C. Hathaway, The Law of Refugee Status(LexisNexis, 1991), p.38. ޱ ġȰ 쿡 ̸ νû 籹 ָϰ ȴٸ ûڴ ȴٰ ƾ Ѵ. James C. Hathaway, The Law of Refugee Status(LexisNexis, 1991), p.39. ٵ ̷ νûڴ ߱ Ͽ ű θ ϰ ġ Ȱ ϴ ô ִ ִٴ ⺻ ϰ ִ ƴѰ ϴ DZ Ѵ. αⱸ ڽ ʷ , ŷڼ Ա Ӽ ϰų (good faith) 䱸ϴ Ϻ , ɼ, ɰ Ǿ ϰ ִ. UNHCR(April 2001), supra note 22, para. 34. ȣ Mohammed v. Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs Mohammed v. Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs, [1999] FCA 868. ִ ٰŰ ִ Ǿ ϴ ̰, ű ɰ ظ ʷϴ ظ ڹ ൿ ʷϿٰ Ͽ ٰ ǽ ִ. , 2001 ̹ι νû ȣ Ȱ νû ȭϱ 쿡 ̸ Ǿ ǡ ǻ ԵǾ. ̹αĢ ǡ ü Ρ ϰ ְ, ٸ νû Ȱ Ȥ ȯ ų̳ ǥϰ ϴ ȮεǴ 쿡 Ư(in particular) ϴٴ ܼ ް ̹Ƿ, Immigration Rules para. 333P. UNHCR 94 100 Ͽ ü Ρ Ϲ ȴ. UK Border Agency of the Home Office, Considering the Asylum Claim(24 April 2009), pp.12-13. http://www.ukba.homeoffice.gov.uk/sitecontent/documents/policyandlaw/asylumprocessguidance/consideringanddecidingtheclaim/guidance/consideringtheasylumclaim.pdf?view=Binary, 2009. 5.31. 湮 ҹ M v. Secretary of State for the Home Departmentǿ νûڰ ۵ǰ ٰ ȣ û 쿡 ó̳ ź ĥ ִٴ ϰ ̿ ٷ νûڸ ȣκ ų ִ ٰŰ ٰ ǽϸ鼭 ܴ Ǿ Ͽ. M v. Secretary of State for the Home Department, [1996] 1 WLR 507. Danian v. Secretary of State for the Home Departmentǿ Ͽ ظ ִٴ ٰŰ ִ ִٰ ִ ûڴ ߱ ǿ ΰ ϰ, ȿ ִ. Danian v. Secretary of State for the Home Department, [2000] Imm. A.R. 96, EWCA. ǽϿ ǡ и Ͽ. ü Ǵ 캸 ۶ ظ ѹα Ա ƴ϶ , ۶ ظ Ա ٸ ܸε Բ JPNK Ͽ ۶ ημ ѱ繫 ϰ ۶ ܸε鿡 ġ ź ȸ ˷, ġ ǰ Ͽ ٸ ܸε , 2005. 8. 18. 200440051 ǰ. ѹα ԱϿ νûϷκ óϱ NLD-LA ѱ ȸ ̾Ḷ ּ¿ ġ ź ȸ ˸, ̾Ḷ տ ν Ȱ ̾Ḷ Կϰ, ġ Ȱ Բ Ͽ ѱ ȸ 21 8 Ǿ, ̾Ḷ ΰ NLD ڻӸ ƴ϶ Ϲ ġ Ͽ ִ , 2006. 2. 3. 200520993 ǰ. ߱η ѱ ημ ѱδ 6.4 õȹ ȸ ϴ Ȱ Ͽ , Ź̳ ͳݰ˻ Ͽ Ȱ ϰ ν ִ 쿡 Ͽ νû Ͽ. 2007. 10. 4. 200637370 ǰ. ѱ Ϲ Ȱ Ȱ Ź , Ȱ 6.4 õȹ ȸ, ͳ ߱ ȭ ܿ ٸ Ȱ νû ߱ ûε Ȱ ָɼ ûε ߱ ο ٸ зµ ʾǷ νû źóп Ͽ ϴٰ ǴϿ. 2006. 12. 12. 200613442 ǰ. ɿ ̾Ḷֵ ѱ ȸμ ѹα Ȱ Ϳ ̾Ḷ ηκ Ȱ ľǵǾ ɼ , ̹ ΰ ϰų ֱ ġ ǰ ǥϴ ڽ ൿ μ ѹα ü Ǿ. ǽϿ ű 籹 ָ ɼ Ǵ Ϻ Ƿʴ ü Ρû θ ǴԿ ־ '(good faith) ǻ ϴ ̱ Ѵ. ü Ρ ٽ Ǵܱ ű 籹 ָ ɼ ϱ ٴ '(good faith) ǻ ֵ Ǵܱ Ǵϴ Ƿʵ Ѵ. û ''(good faith) û ǵ ǻ簡 ƴ ذɼ ǥ Ͽ Կ ұϰ, Ϻ Ƿʴ ġ Ȱ Ͽ OO ", "Ƿ 巯 ٰŷ Ȱ̾ ߴ", "ҹüڷμ ȯǰ Ǿ ̻ Ȱ ̶ νû ", νû "Ű " ѵ ұ Ǵ û ǡ(good faith) ο Ǵ ٽ ϰ ְ, 2007. 9. 4. 20071912 ǰ; 2006. 11. 28. 200623531 ǰ . ɿ û Ȱ ϱ ̶͡ Ǵ ̡ ٰ ǽϿ. 2008. 7. 24. 200719539 ǰ. ó νû Ա, δü Ե Ȥ νû ָϴ ذɼ θ Ǵ 䱸ϴ ִ. 弭, ǰ ⡻(κȣƮũ , 2007. 9), p.7. 3 dz(Internal Flight Alternative) The Michigan Guidelines on the Internal Protection Alternative dz Ȥ ȡ(Internal flight or relocation alternative)ٴ ' ȣ '(Internal protection alternative) Ȯ ǥ ϰ ִ. First Colloquium on Challenges in International Refugee Law, The Michigan Guidelines on the Internal Protection Alternative (April 1999), . ٰŰ ִ ɼ ű Ϻ ȿ ȣ ִٸ ״ 迡 óִٰ µ James C. Hathaway, The Law of Refugee Status(LexisNexis, 1991), p.133. ̴ ȣ ܿ ٸ ̵鿡 ־ ̱ ̴. Andrew E. Shacknove, 'Who Is a Refugee?' Ethics, vol. 95, no. 2, (1985), p.277. ݸ鿡 ű ü 信 䱸ϰų ̸ ϰ ʴ. UNHCR 91: Reinhard Marx, 'The Criteria for Applying the "Internal Flight Alternative" Test in National Refugee Status Determination Procedures', International Journal of Refugee Law, vol. 14, no. 2 (2002), p.179. 1969 äõ ī ī ι Ư īձⱸ 1 2 ű Ǵ Ϻ Ǵ οǡ Ȳ ν ǻ dz Ȥ ȡ ǻ ϰ ִ. ü ģ ش ϴ Ư Ҷ , ؿ ٰŰ ִ ٴ û 忡 ü κμ ٷ Ѵ. Deborah E. Anker, Law of Asylum in the United States, 3rd Ed. (Refugee Law Conter, Inc., 1999), p.56; Reinhard Marx, 'The Criteria for Applying the "Internal Flight Alternative" Test in National Refugee Status Determination Procedures', International Journal of Refugee Law, vol. 14, no. 2 (2002), p.180. dz Ȥ ȡ(Internal flight or relocation alternative) Ǵ û ̾ , νûڰ νû ϱ ȣ ִ Ұ ȮεǾ Ѵٴ ̴. Michael Walton, 'Backgrond Paper on The Refugee Definition', Searching for Solutions: Background Papers for the Executive Committee of the UNHCR Programme - Annual Meeting 2002 (UNHCR, 2002), p.100. dz Ȥ ȡ Ư Ҹ ǹϴµ, ̰ ؿ ٰŰ ִ , Ư Ȳ Ͽ Ͽ ִ ո ǹѴ. ij ҹ Thirunavukkarasu v. Canada Ƿ, ȣ ҹ SZAZX v Milister for Immigration Ƿ ̸ Ȯϰ ִ. ̶ ǿ "" ̰ ƴϴ. ִٰ Ǵ Ͽ ü ߴ ɼ Ѵٴ ɼ Ͽ å ûڿ ִ. ߷п ̰ų ̷ ̾ ȴ. װ ݵ ̰, ִ ̾ Ѵ. Ҵ ûڿ Ͽ Ѵ. ̷ ո̶ ϴ ̰ ûڴ ƴϴ. Thirunavukkarasu v. Canada (Minister of Employment and Immigration) [1994] 1 FC 589 (CA), 10 November 1993 (Canada Federal Court of Appeal). û װ Ҵ ƴ 迡 ٰŰ ִ°̴. ϰ ٵǾ ȴ. ûڰ ٸ ־, װ ո Ͽ ʿ䰡 ִ. ȣ ո ٰ ʴٸ ؿ ٰŰ ִ ̴. SZAZX v Milister for Immigration [2004] FMCA 393 (16 July 2004). ո , ǻ ڴ ûڰ ϴ "ϰ Ȥ" ΰ غƾ Ѵ. Karanakaran v. Secretary of State for the Home Department [2000] EWCA Civ. 11, 25 January 2000 (England and Wales Court of Appeal). , dz Ȥ ȡ ̰, డϰ, ϰ ؾ Ѵ. Niraj Nathawani, Rethinking Refugee Law (Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 2003), p.100. ٰɼ ǹ ִ ȣ Ǿ ϴ ̴. , Ȥ ٸ ٸ ̵ ϴ , ȣ ù, ġ ȸ α ⺻ ؿ ġ ϴ , Ÿ ٸ ̶ ȯ ʰų Ұ νɻ翡 dz Ȥ ȡ Ǿ ȴ. James C. Hathaway, The Law of Refugee Status(LexisNexis, 1991), p.134. ȣ ҹ Al-Amidi v MINA ǿ ո õ ҷ û , , ù ġ Ǹ Թ, ǰ ִ. Al-Amidi v MINA (2000) FCA (4 August 2000). dz Ȥ ȡ Ǵ 信 ϰ ̷ ʾҰ پϰ ϰ ִ. dz Ȥ ȡ ι Ģ̰ų ɻ ƴ κ ִ. UNHCR, Guidelines on International Protection: "Internal Flight or Relocation Alternative" within the Context of Article 1A(2) of the 1951 Convention and/or 1967 Protocol relating to the Status of Refugees, HCR/GIP/03/04(23 July 2003), pp.2-3. ȣ(Internal Protection Alternative) ǽ ٰŷ ٰŰ ִ 縦 ϰ ִ. ؼ ī϶(Kailali) ȸ(Nepali Congress Party: NCP) ִ(Democratic Party Cadre) Ҽ ȰϿ ûڿ Ͽ ī϶ ̽Ʈ ݱκ ظ ־ٰ ϴ, ̽Ʈ ƴ īƮη ̻ Ŀ ̴ ûڰ ̽Ʈ ݱκ ظ ٰŰ ִ ִٰ ϱ ƴٰ ǴϿ, 2008. 4. 11. 200731836 ǰ. ̾Ḷ ģ νûڿ Ͽ ٸ dzó ִٴ ո ִ 쿡 ƴϴ¹ 쿡 ذ Ͼ (ε) ǻ ε ٸ Ȱ ̴ ûڰ Ҽ ̶ ź, , ġ ǰ Ͽ ظ ִٴ ٰŰ ִ ִ ο شѴٰ ٰ ǽϿ. 2008. 5. 14. 200732105 ǰ. ̱ νûڰ ٸ ν ظ ִٸ ûڴ ؿ ٰŰ ִ ʴ´. ϰ ִ. 8 C.F.R. 208.13(b)(2). Ư ʿ õ dzó Ȥ ִ Կ ־ ߱ϰ ٰκ dz ȲӸ ƴ϶ õ 巡 ǹ ִ ִ Ͽ ð ϴ ʿϴ. Januzi v. Secretary of State for the Home Department; Hamid v. Secretary of State for the Home Department; Gaafar v. Secretary of State for the Home Department; Mohammed v. Secretary of State for the Home Department, [2006] UKHL 5, 15 February 2006 (UK House of Lords); Secretary of State for the Home Department (Appellant) v. AH (Sudan) and Others (FC) (Respondents) [2007] UKHL 49, 14 November 2007. Ƿʴ ̽Ʈ ݱ κ ϰ ־ ƴϴ Ȱ ؿԴٴ ǹ̿ dz Ȥ ȡ Ͽٰ ƴ. Ƿʴ ûڰ δ εó ༼ϸ ȰϿ ̾Ḷ̰ ε ű̶ ƴٴ ִٰ Ǵܵȴ. ij ҹ Hurt v. Minister of Manpower and Immigration ǿ νû ֱ ƴ 迡 Ǿ ϰ ֱ ȣɼ δ 迡 ΰ Ȯ Ŀ ɼ ǹ̸ ̶ ǽ ִ. [1978] 2 F.C. 340 (C.A.). ̷ Ƿʿʹ Ư ź ȿ ȮǾ ִ ̾ Ϲ ǽ ɡϴ ϴ, ƴ϶ ̶ ġ ְ, ؿ Ͽ ǽ ϴ, ǽν κ ִٰ ϱ ƴٰ ǽ ִ. 2008. 5. 2. 200724746 ǰ. Ǵ 浹 ϱ Ͽ ٸ ǽ , ǽ ۡ۸ ̽ κ ظ ǰ Ͽ. 2008. 11. 25. 200813776 ǰ. ̾Ḷ ģ 2 ǰῡ 1 Ǵ UNHCR 91 ȿ dz Ȥ ȡ 縦 ϰ ִ. ظ ݵ ü Ȯ ʿ Ǵ Ȳ ߴ ҿ , Ư Ǵ ܿ ش Ϻ , ܼ ٸ dzó ִٴ Ǹδ װ ϴ ո 쿡 ʴ ̹Ƿ( 91 ), ε ĶĿŸ üϿ Դٴ μ ٴ ̴. 2009. 1. 8. 200813608 ǰ. ̻ȸĢ 2004/83/EC 8 ո 롱 ϸ鼭 ϹݻȲ û Ȳ Ͽ ϰ ű ư ƴ϶ ϰ ִ. The Michigan Guidelines on the Internal Protection Alternative First Colloquium on Challenges in International Refugee Law, The Michigan Guidelines on the Internal Protection Alternative (April 1999); Reinhard Marx, 'The Criteria for Applying the "Internal Flight Alternative" Test in National Refugee Status Determination Procedures', International Journal of Refugee Law, vol. 14, no. 2 (2002), pp.184-185. ȣ , (1) 迡 ص, (2) Ȥ ؿ ϴ ߰ , (3) ּ ȣ ְ, ̷ Ǹ ո ɻ ʿϴٰ ϰ ִ. αⱸ Ʒ dz Ȥ ȡ ϱ ü ϰ ִµ dz Ȥ ȡ Ǵ ȿ ̷ ü ؿ ɻ縦 ϰ ִ ǹ̴. I. м(Relevance Analysis) a) ִ ο , ϰ, ٰѰ?: ̷ ϳ Ѵٸ ̴. b) ü ΰ?: ü ȰѴٰ ȴ. ڶ, dz Ȥ Ģ ʴ ȴ. c) ü üΰ?: ü õ ûڸ Ѵٸ dz Ȥ . ̷ ڰ ûڸ ɼ ִ, طκ ȣ ϰ ȴ. d) ֿ Ͽ ûڰ ̳ ٸ ɰ ؿ ΰ?: ̰ Ȥ ο Ǵ ٸ ɰ ظ Ѵ. II. ո м(Reasonableness Analysis) ƶ, ûڰ 뿡 ʰ ִ°?: ʴٸ װ ϴ ո ʴ. UNHCR, Guidelines on International Protection: "Internal Flight or Relocation Alternative" within the Context of Article 1A(2) of the 1951 Convention and/or 1967 Protocol relating to the Status of Refugees, HCR/GIP/03/04(23 July 2003), p.3. 4 ظ Դٴ νûڵ 忡 ظ ʾҴٴ ٰŰ ִ ϴ ߿ ٰ ϳ ǽϰ ִ. ϰ ϴ Ҵ 簡 ϴ ұ Ұ ̴. 1951 ŵ Ͽ ̹ ڰ Ǿٸ, װ ظ ִ ٰŰ ִ ִ. ظ ̵Ӹ ƴ϶ Ű Ȳ ϰ ϴ ̵ õȴ. UNHCR 45; Dirk Vanheule, 'United States', Carlier, Jean-Yves, Vanheule, Dirk, Hullmann, Klaus and Galiano, Calos Pena (eds.), Who Is a Refugee? A Comparative Case Law Study (Kluwer, 1997), p.619. ش ൵ 巡 κ ȣ ϰ ظ ʴ´. Deborah E. Anker, Law of Asylum in the United States, 3rd Ed. (Refugee Law Conter, Inc., 1999), p.32. ݸ鿡 Ű ϰ Ǹ, װ ٷ νûڰ ǹϴ ƴ, װ νû ȯ ִ Ͽ ǽ Ȯ ǥ ִ. 巡 ɼ ϰ ߿ Ȳ ȭ , Ư Ͽ 巡 ؿ ִ ̴. James C. Hathaway, The Law of Refugee Status(LexisNexis, 1991), pp.87-88; John Vrachnas, Kim Boyd, Mirko Bagaric and Penny Dimopoulos, Migration and Refugee Law: Principles and Practice in Australia, 2nd Ed. (Cambridge University Press, 2008), pp.255-257. ij ̹ҹ Guillermo Lautaro Diaz Fuentes Guillermo Lautaro Diaz Fuentes, (1974), 9 I.A.C. 341, per J. P. Houle; ذ ̹ Ͽٴ ǿ ʴ´ٴ и Ͽ, ҹ 簡 κ ٰŷ ۿϴ Ϳ Ͽ и ϰ ִ. (̹)ȸ ûڿ Ͼ ̡ü ʾұ ؿ ̸ ʴٰ δ. ̷ν ȸ¡ Ͼ ü ° ִ Ӹ ƴ϶, , 1973 1974 ϵ Բ, ظ ִٴ ٰŰ ִ ٰŰ ִ ϴ Ͽ. Alfredo Manuel Oyarzo Marchant v. Minister of Employment and Immigration, [1982] 2 F.C. 781, per Thurlow C.J. ij ҹ ȮϿµ, Francisco Humberto Gonzalez Galindo ǿ ִ Ƿ Ÿ ʾҴٴ ̹ȸ ôϸ鼭 Ŵ νû ġȰ ߴٴ ȸ ҽĽŰ ִ Ű ִٰ ǽϿ. Francisco Humberto Gonzalez Galindo, [1981] 2 F.C. 781 (C.A.). ̱ ظ ϳ ϰ ִ. ← End |
|
|
← Previous
[1][2][3][4][5] 6
|
[Category]
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Copyright 1997-2024
TAX & LAW (ݰ )
site ϴ ƴϸ, ̰ "" Ƿ(¶ ƴ϶ å Ⱓ Ƿ) Ǹ մϴ. , Ƿʿ Ȥö ִٸ, װ ƴϸ, Ͽ ̰ų ̶ Ͻñ ٶϴ. ұϰ ̸ ̶ ϽŴٸ, ϴ Ʈ ƴ϶ Ͽ (å Ⱓ Ƿ) Ƿ Ͻʽÿ. 繫ǿ Ͻ κ ƴմϴ. |
FEE Ұ |
| |
λ |
| |
TAX |
| |
뵿 |
| |
|
| |
Ư PAT ǥ |
| |
Ѽ |
| |
ART |
| |
|
| |
|
| |
USA ̹ VISA |
| |
ȥ |
| |
Foreign Clients |
| | | |
|
|