[TAX & LAW] ȣ(KO, USA, IL)
I P

[ѱȣ, ̱ȣ, ϸ ȣ, ]
Since 1997 [ 繫 츦 ϰ Ἥ񽺴 ü ʽϴ.]
Ἥ񽺳 FEE, ޴ ȳ(Click) Ͻʽÿ.
ȣ ̳ , з  ȣ Ұ Ǵ ȣ ޴ ϼ


ATTORNEY [ licensed to practice in KOREA, U.S.A., ILLINOIS ] LEE, JAE WOOK
∗ [FOR AlienS - ENGLISH LANGUAGE LEGAL SERVICES in Counseling, Application and LITIGATION & TRIAL IN COURTS and TRIBUNALS in KOREA]
INTERNATIONAL DIVORCE, CIVIL, REAL ESTATE, PERSONAL INJURY, DAMAGES, TRAFFIC ACCIDENT, FRAUD, PENAL LAW, CRIMINAL TRIAL, FELONY, GUILTY PLEA, LEASE, RENTAL LAW, IMMIGRATION, INVESTMENT, TAX, INCORPORATION, TRADE, CONTRACT, DISPUTE IN CORPORATION, GOVERNMENT TREATMENT, REFUGEE, REMOVAL, VISA, PERMANENT RESIDENCE, CITIZENSHIP]
For more information for the services Attorney LEE provide for the Aliens who want for legal services in Korea, Please do not hesitate to click the below MENU link for "SERVICES FOR AlienS".

∗ [LANGUAGE Translation] You can use Google Translate application to see in your own language the pages in this website. For your convenience, click the "Google Translate(Select Language)"



FEE
Ұ
| λ

|
TAX
|

뵿
|

| Ư
PAT
ǥ
|

Ѽ
|
ART
|

|

| USA
̹
VISA
| ȥ

| Foreign
Clients
| |
[Category]
REFUGE, ASYLUM IN KOREA
  • retainer fee
  • consulting fee
  • Resume of Attorney LEE
  • REFUGE, ASYLUM IN KOREA
  • Self Advocacy Statement for case
  • VISA IN KOREA
  • REMOVAL, DEPORTATION
  • B VISA
  • C VISA
  • D VISA
  • E VISA
  • F VISA
  • G VISA
  • H VISA
  • STAY, EXTENSION, CHANGE OF STATUS
  • PASSPORT OF KOREA
  • ADMISSION INSPECTION INTO KOREA
  • IMMIGRATION LAW OF KOREA
  • INVESTMENT IN KOREA
  • EMPLOYMENT IN KOREA
  • NATURALIZATION IN KOREA
  • MARRIAGE IN KOREA
  • 뿪(translation, interpretation)
  • china visa
  • Death of Aliens, Estate, Proof of Death
[Category]
REFUGE, ASYLUM IN KOREA


[Title]
Ƿ ؼ - ٰŰ ִ ؼ 2009. 9. 14. 溯ȣȸ μҼ ̳ ڷ Ƿʺм: ߽Ρ ․ .
Start →

Ƿ ؼ
- ٰŰ ִ ؼ 2009. 9. 14. 溯ȣȸ μҼ ̳ ڷ Ƿʺм: ߽Ρ ․ .


Ȳʱ

1 ѱ Ȳ ׿

    α̻ȸ(Human Rights Council) 2008 6 12 ä HRC, Outcome of the universal periodic review: Republic of Korea, UN Doc. A/HRC/DEC/8/123, 12 June 2008.
αǻȲ ѱο 1951 1967 ϰ, ι ϵ ϶󡱴 ǰ Ͽ. HRC, Report of the Working Group on the Universal Periodic Review: Republic of Korea, UN Doc. A/HRC/8/40, 29 May 2008, para. 64.30.  
öȸ(Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination) 2007 8 17 ѱ κ ؿ ΰ Ͽ û ǻ ȭ Ͽ ȿ ѵ ûڵ鸸 ް ִ. ǥϰ, ΰ νûڿ ѱ Ÿ ε ص鿡 Ǿ Ѵ. 鼭 Ư ϰ żϰ ̷ϰ, νûڿ ε ȣ ο ־ϸ, ѱȸ ε Ű ġ äõǾ Ѵ. ǰϰ ִ. CERD, Concluding observations of the Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination: Republic of Korea, UN Doc. CERD/C/KOR/CO/14, 17 August 2007, para. 10
ټ ߻ ѱ õ 巯ְ ִ.
    1992 12 ѱ 1951 (the 1951 Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees) 1967 (the 1967 Protocol Relating to the Status of Refugees) Ͽ, 1993 12 Ա װ żϿ, 1994 7 Ա ȿǾ 1994 ó νû ϰ Ǿ. ׷ DZ 2000 ѱ αⱸ ȸ ̴. 1994 2008 12 31 15Ⱓ ü νûڴ 2,168 Ұ, ü νû 50.5% 1,286 ɻ ̰, ɻ簡 879 101, ġȲ ε ü 㰡 71̴. ü û 4.7% ſ ִ. Ա․ܱå, Ա․ܱå 2008 12ȣ(2009. 1.), p.35.
ó νû Ѽ, Ȳ, ΰ õ ü ࿡ ɰ 巯ְ ִ.  

2

     Ȳ ʿ μ DZ ߻Ѵ. μ ׸ ǰ ϴ ƴ϶, μ ϴ ̴. װ ޱ Ǵ ƴ϶, ̱ Ǵ ̴. UNHCR 28; ̻ȸĢ 2004/83/EC (14) Ȯϰ ִ.

     ǰ鵵 â ƴϹǷ ϸ 翬 ࿡ ο شѴ ̶͡ ϸ鼭 ݰ Ͽ ǽϿ Դ. 2007. 6. 27. 200621643 ǰ; 2001. 8. 16. 991990 ǰ; 2009. 4. 30. 200844228 ǰ .  


     ü౹ Ͽ ࿡ ο Ͽ ׻ ̸ ޾Ƶ鿩 ȣ οϵ ǹ ƴϸ( 12 1ȣ ), ο ȣ ο , οѴٸ  δ Ϲ ü౹ ֱ صǰ ִ.
    , Ա 762 1 ܱκ û ִ ܱ ִٰ ϰ ׿ Ǵ ο  οǴ Ͽ ƹ ΰ , ̴ Ͽ ش ܱο üڰ οϴ ȣ 翬 ԵǾ ִ ؼ ϴ ̰, ǰ ܼ ûڰ  ߾ Ȯϴ ǹ̿ ġ ( κп ǰ 緮 ), ܱο Ǹ οϴ μ ̿ Ͽ ǰ 緮 ο ƾ ̴.
     ǰ ܱο û  μ ߾ θ Ȯ , Ǵ 쿡 ̸ ʷ ׸ Ա 762 1 Ͽ üڰ ο ȣ ο , ƴϸ ʿ ұϰ 3 ŽŰų ȣ ¸ ο 緮 Ͽ Ѵ( Ǵ ִ ߹ϰų ȯϴ 33 1ȣ Ͽ ǰ ִ).
            
     Ա 緮 ǴϿ νû 켱  μ ߾ θ ǴϿ ش缺 , ο ش ȣ ο ο Ͽ 緮 Ͽ Ѵٰ Ǵϰ ִ. , Ա ش缺θ Ǵϰ , ȣοʿ伺 θ Ǵϴ 2ܰ ľ ϴ Ǯϰ ִ. ̷ 2ܰ Ǵܱؿ Ͽ "緮 翡 ռ  ߾ ο ׸ ʿ 緮 縦 ó Ͽ Ҹ Ѵ." ϰ ִ. ̴ 1ܰ Ǵؾ ϴ ش缺 ο Ͽ ߸ ǴϿ ο شԿ ұϰ ش缺 ׸ ȣο 緮 ʾ ϴٰ Ǵ ̴. ü ο ǰῡ ü Ǹ 쿡 Ͽ Ǿ Ѵ١ ôϸ鼭 ̰ ο ü ⺸ٴ ȣ ο ϴ١ ǽϿ ġ ü 簡 ȣ ο ϴ ִ ϰ ִ. 2006. 5. 10. 200519643 ǰ.
    
    ̷ Ƿ µ ұϰ ǵ ǿ ϸ鼭 ȣ ο Ǵ Ƿʴ . ̴ ΰ Կ ־ ̸ ϴ 쿡 ǿ شѴٴ ޸ ϰ ְ, ̸ ϴ 쿡 ǿ ش ʴ´ٴ ־ ȣ ο ΰ Ǵ ʰ ̶ ִ. ٸ μ ü 緮 ٶν ܱ , ߽ Ա å , Ư ̵ ֹο öϰ ν γ Ǵܿ ־ ߿ ϰ ۿ ִ ϰ ִٴ 򰡰 ϴ.        
    ̷ Ƿ µ ǹ Ϲݰ ࿡ ׸ ؼ ϰ ִٰ Ǵܵȴ. μ, ' ¿ ̳ й', 溯ȣȸ, ¿ ̳(2008. 7. 15.), pp.80-83; ö, '2007 κо α ', ֻȸ ȣ , 2007 ѱαǺ(2008. 1.), p.449; Ȳʱ, ' ', Ѻȣȸ, 2007 αǺ(2008. 3.), pp.544-545 .  
켱, 6 1׿ Ͽ ü, ࡯μ ȿ¡ . ǼҴ ̿ Ͽ 6 1 Ǵ 츮 Ϲ ε ԰ ȿ ٴ ͡ Ǽ 2001. 4. 26. 99尡13 .
̶ Ͽ ǹ̸ Ȯϰ ִ. 2׿ Ͽ ࡯  Ͽ ܱΡ 塯ȴ. ̴ ױ ȭ η ̹ ǥϰ ִ ȭ ·μ Ͽ ּ ܱ Ȯ ؿ Ͽ ܱ ȣϰڴٴ ִ صǰ ִ. Ǽ 1991. 7. 22. 89尡106 , Ǽ 2001. 4. 26. 99尡13 .
, ϰ  ѹα μ ȿ 뿡 Ͽ ȴٰ ϰڴ.
    °, ǰ 12 1ȣ ٰŷ ̶ ϴ ȣ ο ο ȣ ο ü౹ ֱ μ ǰ Ȥ 緮 οȴٰ ǽϰ ִ. ׷ , Ͽٴ ǹ̴ ̸ ȿ Թ ϰ ο ȣ ο ǹ ޾Ƶ鿴ٴ ̴. 12 1ȣ Ͽ ּ Ȥ ż ϵ Ǿִ Ϲ ƴ϶ , ģ źл ǹϴ μ Ǹɷ, ȥδɷ, , ӱ Ѵ. Nehemiah Robinson, Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees: Its History, Contents and Interpretation(Institute of Jewish Affairs, 1953), p.24; Guy S. Goodwin-Gill and Jane McAdam, The Refugee in International Law, 3rd Ed.(Oxford, 2007), p.527; Hathaway, James C., The Rights of Refugees under International Law(Cambridge, 2005), p.209; źС ϵ ǰ . ٸ  쿡 װ ɷ( ñ, ̼ Ǹ, ȥδɷ, ȥ ɷ, ɷ (İ) Ѵ. Ծ, , ȥ, ȥ, ģ, Ǹ ϲ ȴ. Paul Weis, The Refugee Convention, 1951: The Travaux Preparatoires Analysed(Cambridge University Press, 1995), p.107.
̴ ϴ Ǹ, Ư ȥο ϴ Ǹ 2ȣ , 13, 14, 15, 16, 3, ȸ 4 뿡 ߾ ϴ. 12 1ȣ ٰŷ ο ȣ ο ־ 緮 ϴ 뿡 ׸ ؼ ۿ .    
    °, ǰ Ա Ͽ ϰ ƴ ؼ üڰ οϴ ȣ 翬 ԵǾ ִ ؼϿ ϱ Ա Ȯϴ Ͱ Ǵ ϹǷ 緮 οǾ ִٰ ƾ Ѵٰ ǽϰ ִ. ׷ Ǹ ϰ ִ ƴ϶ ٿ Ǹ ü ϰ ְ ̵ ȿ¡ Ƿ Ա ٰ Ͽ ̸ ϰ ƴϴٰ Ǵ ̴. ٸ Ǵ Ǹ üȭŰ Ǹ ġǴ Ź켱 Ģ̳ Ư켱 Ģ ϴ ´. ࿡ Ǹ ٰ Ǵϴ ü౹ ƴϴ Ϻ ִ¹ ѹα ̷ ȣ 7 2ȣ 7 1ȣ Ͽ ִ. Ȯ ϰ Ͽ 緮 οǾ ִٰ ϴ ٰŰ Ǵ ۿ ִ.
    °, ǰ ߾ ϴ Ա 762 1 Ͽ üڰ ο ȣ ο 緮̸, ̶ ϴ 3 ų ȣ ϴٰ ǽϰ ִ. ̴ Ӹ ƴ϶ ϴ ȿ ϴ 6 ݵǴ Ǵ̴. ü౹ ̻ û ִ 쿡 ɻ縦 ź Ͽ DZ⸸ ϸ Ÿ ɿ ǹ ߻Ѵٰ ƾ Ѵ.
    ټ°, Ա 762 1 ִ. Ͽ ó(Ư ȣ ο) ǻ 緮 , ̴ ȭο ؼ Ÿϸ, ٸ ѱ ȣؾ ǹ Ȯϰ Ѵٴ ǹ̿ Ͽ Ѵ. Ͽ ٲٴ ؾ ʿ䰡 ִ.
    ̷ ؿ Ͽ, ׵ ִ ü ܰ а νŰ ְ ε鿡 ֿ ȸ ͵ üڰݰ εǾ ִµ, ѱ ûϴ ܱ κ üڰ μ ̵ û ٷ Ⱓ üڰ ο ǹ ȣ ϴ μ, ȣ ομ 緮 ϴ ̷ ǹ ȣ ǹ Ȯ ʾҴٴ Ѵٰ ϸ鼭 µ ϴ ذ ִ. 輺, ' ¿ ̳ й', 溯ȣȸ, ¿ ̳(2008. 7. 15.), pp.92-93.

    ׷, ȣ Ͽ ࿡ ٽ ƾ κ ȯ Ģ̴. ̿ ٰϿ ü౹ ϰ, ο ؼ װ ظ ɼ ִ ǹ ȴ. ̷ ǹ ǹ̴ ε ׵ û ӹ ִ Ǹ γ ް ȴٴ ̴. ؾ ȣ ο ִٴ DZ ƴ.          
    , ܼ ü(simple presence), ü(legal presence) Ǵ (legal residence) ٸ Ǹ Ǵ ü ȣ ο 緮 ǹ̰ ƴ϶ ̶ Ͽ Ǿ ο ٸ ó Ȥ ȣ ִٴ ǹ̸, Ͽ 쿡 ȣ ޾ƾ Ѵٴ Ÿְ ִٰ ְ, James C. Hathaway, The Rights of Refugees under International Law(Cambridge, 2005), pp.156-160 .
ȣ 뵵 ü ڰ ־ٴ ̻ ǹ̸ ϴ 巯ְ ִ. Alice Edwards, Human Rights, Refugees, and the Right To Enjoy Asylum, International Journal of Refugee Law, vol. 17, no. 2 (2005), pp.302-303.
      
     ش αǼ(Universal Declaration of Human Rights) 14 1 ٸ 󿡼 طκ ȣ ϰ Ǹ ϿǷ ȣ ο ǹ δ  ȣ ο Ǹ ؼ ɼ ִٰ Ѵ. Niraj Nathawani, Rethinking Refugee Law (Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 2003), p.131.
̴ ӷ ִ 1966 ù ġ Ǹ Ծ(International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights) Ե Ͽ, 1969 ȸ ȣ (Declaration on Territorial Asylum) ұϰ ȣ (Convention on Territorial Asylum) üϷ 1977 õ ȸ Ǹμ ޾Ƶ鿩 Ѱ踦 Ȯνְ ִٰ Ѵ. 輺, ' ¿ ̳ й', 溯ȣȸ, ¿ ̳(2008. 7. 15.), pp.93-94.
ο ȸ Ϲ Ǵ ȣ ʴ´ٴ Ϲ ̴. Sam Blay and Andreas Zimmermann, 'Recent Changes in German Refugee Law: A Critical Assessment', American Journal of International Law, vol. 88, no. 2 (April 1994), p362.  
      
    ׷, Ϲ ȣο ǹ ϴ°  ǹ ° Sylvie Da Lomba, The Right to Seek Asylum Status in the European Union(Intersentia, 2004), pp.8-9.
ش ڸ ȥϿ ǻ Ͻϴ 弱 Ǹ ϰ ִ. αǼ ȣ Ǹ ϰ ȣ ο ǹ ʾҴٴ ̸, 籹 Ǵ ο Ͽ οϿ ǹ , 鿡 Ϲ ȣ ο ǹ ϴ ƴϴ. Ư ȣ ǹ̰ ֱ οѴٴ ǹ̶ ̸ ο ǹ ִٰ . Geoff Gilbert, 'Is Europe Living Up to Its Obligations to Refugees?', European Journal of International Law, vol. 15, no. 5 (2004), p.965  
ȣ ࿡ ǵ ᱹ ̷ ǹ Ϲȭϱ õ з ư ǹ ̰, ȿ ѱ ѱ ࿡ ٰ ӷ ִ ǹ δϴ Ͱ ٸ ̴. Guy S. Goodwin-Gill and Jane McAdam, The Refugee in International Law, 3rd Ed.(Oxford, 2007), pp.358-365 .
ڱ üϴ ο Ͽ ࿡ ٰϿ ȯ Ģ ϴ ü ȣ οϴ ؼϴ ´ٰ ƾ Ѵ. Gina Clayton, Textbook on Immigration and Asylum Law, 5th Ed. (Oxford University Press, 2004), p.346; James A. Sweeney, 'The Lure of 'Facts' in Asylum Appeals: Critiquing the Practice of Judges', Steven R. Smith, (ed.), Applying Theory to Policy and Practice: Issues for Critical Reflection(Ashgate, 2007), p.21.
ִ ȯ ʰ 𿣰 ü ڰ ־ٴ ٷ ȣ ٽ̱ ̴.            
    ֱ ϱ޽ Ƿʵ ټ ٸ ǥ ϰ ִ. Ա 2 22ȣ, 762 1, 1, 1 Ͽ , û ִ ϴ Ͽ Ѵ. ǽϿ ϰ ִ. 2008. 7. 24. 200719539 ǰ; 2009. 7. 15. 2009331 ǰ .
׷ ̷ ǽð ش缺 Ǵܰ ȣοʿ伺 Ǵ 2ܰ 򰡸 䱸ϴ ϱ޽ Ƿʵ 弱 ̷ ̶ ش缺 Ǵ Ϳ ҰϹǷ Ƿʵ Ͽ ο ٰ ִ. δ Ƿʵ ǿ ƴ϶ ؼ ӿ ̷ ǽö Ƿʵ ߸ Ǹ ϴ ǹ̸ ְڴ. ̷ ǰṮ ߴٴ ߾ ڷ ؼ , ǽ ü ڷ ؼ , ڷ ؼDZ ؼ ϱ޽ Ƿʵ ֵ Ȯ Ͽ ϸ, ǰ Ŀ ϱ޽ ǰῡ ǽø ״ ݺϰ ִ 2008. 9. 25. 200731911 ǰ; 2009. 4. 30. 200844228 ǰ .
忡 ȭ ִٰ Ǵϴ ִٰ ϰڴ.    
3 Ǵܱ

     ٰŰ ִ Ͽ ׵ ϰǰ νû ְ ɸ° Ȳ Ͽ ޹ħǾ Ͽ Դ.

     DZ ؼ û ؿ ͸δ ϰ ٰŸ 䱸Ѵ. ̴ û ְ ɸ° Ȳ Ͽ ޹ħǾ ǹϴµ , ո ûο ־ Ͱ ü Ȳ ӿ ̴ ؿ Ǵܵȴٸ ٰŸ ϴ.
     ׸ ûο ־ ü Ȳ ǴԿ û ϴ Ϲ αǻȲ Ͽ , ư ׿ û Ϲ Ȳ  ü ӿ ûο ɼ ִ Ͽ Ǿ (). 2007. 6. 27. 200621643 ǰ; 2001. 8. 16 991990 ǰ.
  

     ֱ ϱ޽ Ͽ ٰŰ ִ Ͽ Ǵ ذ Ģ ϰ ִ.

     Ǵ ء , ü Ǵ Ͽ ΰ ߴ ħس ߱ϴ ̰, ׷ ظ ٰ ִ û ϴ ܱ Ͽ ̳, Ư Ͽ ܱο ſ Ͽ ü ϵ 䱸 ϰ ְ, Ա , Ա νû Ⱓ, û , Ȳ, ְ , ûڰ ϴ ġ․ȸ․ȭ ȯ, Ȳ  ߾ ü ź Ͽ ϴ ո 쿡 ִٰ ̴. 2008. 7. 24. 200719539 ǰ; 2009. 5. 15. 200844259 ǰ .
  

     Ƿʰ ٰŰ ִ 信 Ǹ νû ְ ɸ° Ȳ Ͽ ޹ħǾ Ѵٰ ǽϰ ְ, Ǵ ٰŷμ ְ ûڰ ְ ûڰ ϴ Ȳ ְ, ҷμ û Ա Ρ, Ա νû Ⱓ, û , Ȳ, ûڰ ϴ ġ․ȸ․ȭ ȯ桯 ִ Ϳ ߾ ․ Ҹ ϴ ϰ ִٰ 򰡵 ִ.
    Ƿʰ ϰ ִ Ȳ ûڰ ϴ ġ․ȸ․ȭ ȯ桯 ٸ ҵ  ؿ Ͽ õǾ, ׸ κȣ  ǹ̸ Һиϴ. Աϸ鼭 νû ʴ ԱΡ, νû  Ͽ ϰ ϱ ư, Ա Ρ, Ա νû Ⱓ, û Ϲ νûڰ ѱ Ͽ ٷ û ʴ Ҹϰ ۿ ɼ . , ǹ̡ й, б αǹ, - ǡ(2009. 4. 14.), pp.88-89.
׸ ־ ļϴ ٿ ̵ ҵ ׻ νû ٰŰ ִ ϴ ҷ ۿϰ ִ. ̷ ҵ ޿ ־ Ͽ ϰ, ̸ 쿡 װ ǹ̿ Ͽ Ȯ ʿ䰡 ִ ̴.      
    ְ ҿ ؼ Ƿʿ ̸ ϰ ʴ ãƺ Ա Ⱑ Ȱ ̶ų νû Ⱑ ü ϱ ̶ ôϱ ־ û , ְ Ҹ Ǵϰ ִ. ٰŰ ִ ְ ҿ Ῡ ο νû ǽû, Ҽ ࿡ ̸ κ , ڰ ʴ , Ģμ ְ ҿ 򰡸 ϸ鼭 δ Ȥ ɼ̶ Ҹ ִ ƴѰϴ ǹ ۿ δ. ٸ Ϻ Ƿʴ б Ͽ ɷµ Ȳ ϸ Ϻ Һиϰų ִ ̸ Ҹ 縦 ϱ ư, ư ؿ ν ٸ ɼ 2008. 5. 2. 200724746 ǰ. ׷ ǰ 2008. 11. 25. 200813776 ǰῡ ҵǾ.
ǽø ְ Ҹ ϸ鼭 ְ Ұ ϴٰ ϴ Ұ õǸ ٰŰ ִ ִٴ ϰ ִ. ֱ ǰ ߿ ְ ϴ ϴ ǰ ־ Ƿ ָ ʿ䰡 ִٰ Ǵܵȴ.

Ȱ Ⱓ ª Ȱ Ͽٰ ε () ηκ ٸ ź̳ ø ƴϿٰ ϳ, ظ ִٴ ٰŰ ִ ְ μ( 37 ), ̷ Ǵ ݵ û ڽ 迡 ٰ ʿ , ģ, Ǵ Ǵ ȸ ٸ 鿡 Ͼ , û ڰ ̶ ٰŰ ִ ϴ Ǵ ε( 43 ), () ΰ ۡ鿡 Ͽ źå ϰ ְ θ ̷ ȯǰų Ͽ ̻, ڽ () ȯ ظ ̶ Ϳ ٰŰ ִ. 209. 1. 8. 200813608 ǰ.
            

4 å

     ٰŰ ִ åӰ ؼ ϰǰ å ϴ ִٰ ̳, ݻ ̳ ɼ, ο ڷḦ ϴ Ϲ̶ ̹Ƿ, ־ ο ڷῡ Ͽ ü ϵ 䱸 ü ź ȴ , ̸ ؼ  üμ ϰ ߾ ϰ Ϲ ˷ ִ ǰ ݵǾ ȴ. 2007. 6. 27. 200621643 ǰ; 2001. 8. 16. 991990 ǰ.
Ͽ Ư ϰ ִ. ֱ åӰ Ͽ û ŷڼ ִ Ǹ, 忡 ϴ , Ű ûڿ ؼ (benefit of the doubt) οϿ Ѵ. Ͽ ʾҴ ؼ ͺο" Ģ ǰῡ ü ϰ ִ. 2008. 2. 20. 200722115 ǰ.

    ׷ ϰ ü ϱ⺸ٴ û̳ شڵ ؼ ⺻ ŷڼ ǹ ٶ󺸴 ǽø ϱ⵵ Ѵ. 2008. 11. 19. 200811497 ǰ.        
ó Ҹ ǰ κе νû Ȱ̳ ׷ 忡 Ͽ ̸ ϰ ʰ, 弭, ǰ ⡻(κȣƮũ , 2007. 9), p.6.
ظ 䱸ϴ 2009. 1. 13. 200821591 ǰ.  
δ ټ å 䱸ϰ ִ. νûڿ ذɼ Ǵ ɼ(50%̻ ɼ)' غٵ ո ɼ(10%̻ ɼ)' ϴ ȣ ϰ Ƿ̸, ؼϴ ࿡ 񿣳 ؼ Ģ ϹǷ ܼ Ư ϴ ϰ Ȯ ġ ǰ ڸ ٶ ʷ 輺 ٺϹǷ, ϹݼҼ ü  ̰ ִ ü ް Ư Ģ Ȯ ʿϴٰ ϰڴ. Ȳʱ, ' ', Ѻȣȸ, 2007 αǺ(2008. 3.), 14, p.550.  


5 縦 ϴ ٰŵ

1 Ƿ Ϲ

   νûڿ μ ִµ ̷ ũ ϴ , ְ ϴ , ׸ ź ü ϴ ũ ִ. ٸ ü ․ Ҹ ϴ ü  ϳ ⺻ ․ Ұ Բ 򰡵ǰ ִٰ ƾ ϰ ̵ ϰ зϴ ִٰ ϰڴ.
    Ƿʴ Ȳ νûڰ ϴ ذ ɼ , ظ , ذ ʰų, 2007. 9. 4. 20071912 ǰ; 2001. 8. 16. 991990 ǰ .
ظ Ű , 2007. 12. 26. 20078256 ǰ .
ü ζ Ű ų 2008. 7. 3. 2008725 ǰ; 2007. 11. 30. 200726615 ǰ.
û̳ ظ ̿ ̶ ϱ , 2008. 11. 11. 2008732 ǰ; 2007. 12. 6. 200727250 ǰ .
ظ ظ ޾ ذ κ ؼҵǾų ؼҵ ִ , 2007. 6. 8. 200626233 ǰ .
, 2007. 6. 27. 200621643 ǰ; 2001. 8. 16. 991990 ǰ .
 Ȯϰų ü Ῡ, 2008. 1. 24. 200717092 ǰ; 2001. 8. 16. 991990 ǰ .
ܼ ҹ ܱ ü Ȥ û, 2001. 8. 16. 991990 ǰ .
ű Ȥ ̻ , 2007. 6. 27. 200621643 ǰ; 2003. 12. 23. 200223632 ǰ .
ѱ Ա, ü Ȥ ѱ ü νû , 2008. 11. 11. 20085720, 20085737(), 20085744(), 20085751(), 20085768() ǰ; 2008. 6. 13. 200868 ǰ .
Ȱ, Ȱ Ա ѱԱ, 2007. 9. 4. 20071912 ǰ; 2003. 12. 23. 200223632 ǰ .
ѱ Ȱ νû( ֹο Ұϴٰ ), 2008. 7. 24. 200719539 ǰ; 2007. 6. 27. 200621643 ǰ; 2006. 8. 24. 20069320 ǰ .
νû (Ա Ⱓ ϰ üⰣ Ȥ Ŀ ܼ ȭ Ȳ û, 2008. 7. 3. 2008725 ǰ; 2003. 12. 23. 200223632 ǰ .
û ü ̳ , Ȥ ü ̳ , Ǵ νû 2008. 11. 11. 20083526 ǰ; 2007. 11. 27. 20075837 ǰ .
Ȥ ҹüڷ ܼӵ νû 2007. 9. 4. 20071912 ǰ; 2003. 12. 23. 200223632 ǰ .
), Ա Ȥ Ա ѱ Ȱ ų ұ Ȱ Ұ , 2008. 7. 24. 20081344 ǰ; 2007. 5. 25. 200620022 ǰ; 2006. 2. 3. 200520993 ǰ .
Ƿ 巯ų νûϿ ϰų Ŀ Ȱ ϴ ٰŷ Ȱ , 2007. 9. 4. 20071912 ǰ; 2006. 11. 28. 200623531 ǰ .
ҼӴü ֿ׿ 2008. 8. 21. 2008503 ǰ; 2007. 10. 5. 200625209 ǰ .
Ȥ ⵶ û Ȥ ⵶  , 2007. 9. 19. 20074355 ǰ; 2008. 1. 9. 20078768 ǰ .
¡ źϰų ݱ ȸ Ϲκ ȭ ߵ ƴ Ϲ , 2007. 12. 26. 20078256 ǰ .
Ȥ ؿ شϴ ߴ αħ , 2008. 11. 25. 200813776 ǰ; 2007. 10. 17. 200710075 ǰ .
ѱ Ա ȹ 2008. 6. 13. 200868 ǰ.
Ȥ ƴ ѹα ۿ ̺, 2007. 9. 19. 20074355 ǰ; 2007. 6. 8. 200626233 ǰ .
ⱹ ÿ νû , 2008. 7. 24. 20081344 ǰ; 2007. 6. 27. 200621643 ǰ; 2006. 11. 28. 200623531 ǰ
ȣ(Internal Protection Alternative) ǽ , 2008. 4. 11. 200731836 ǰ .
Ȯ ϰų ˷ ǰ ٸ , 2008. 7. 3. 2008725 ǰ; 2003. 12. 23. 200223632 ǰ .
ź ٴ 2008. 7. 24. 20081344 ǰ; 2007. 9. 19. 20074355 ǰ; 2001. 8. 16. 991990 ǰ .  
ٰŷ ٰŰ ִ 縦 ϰ , Ư ü ôϴ ٰŷ δü Ἲ Ե νû ñ, νû Ȱ ٰŷ ִ. 弭, ǰ ⡻(κȣƮũ , 2007. 9), p.6
׷ ̷ Ǵ õ Ȯ ΰ ִ ֱ , Ǵܿ ־ ǿ š Ͽ ϰ, ûڰ ȣ ġ 족 ִٴ Ǵܿ 翬 ʾƾ ϱ Ǵϴ ü ̰ ְ ǴܿҰ Ե ƴϿ Ѵ UNHCR 202 .
Ģ ġ ٺϴ.  
                  
2 ü Ρ(refugee sur place) ǡ(good faith)

     DZ Ͽ ۿ ־ ϴ , ݵ νûڰ ҹ ϰ, Ǵ ٰŰ ִ ǹϴ ƴϸ, UNHCR 94 .
̹ ΰ ϰų Ǵ ֱ ġ ǰ ǥϴ Ͱ ڽ ൿ μ ֱ ü ߿ ִ. Vigdis Vevstad, Refugee Protection: A European Challenge(Tano Aschehoug, 1998), pp.53-54; John Vrachnas, Kim Boyd, Mirko Bagaric and Penny Dimopoulos, Migration and Refugee Law: Principles and Practice in Australia, 2nd Ed. (Cambridge University Press, 2008), p.257.
ٸ û Ͽ ظ ʷѴٴ ⸦ 캼 ʿ䰡 ְ Ư ׷ ൿ 籹 ָ ִ Ǵ ׷ ൿ 籹 Ͽ  Ǵܵ Ͽ Ѵ(UNHCR 96).  
     2001 ̷ Ǵ ɼ ݵ κ ⱹ ÿ Ͽ ϴ ƴϴ١ Ͽ ü Ρ ϸ鼭 ûڰ Ͽ ظ ʷѴٴ ⸦ 캼 ʿ䰡 ְ ޱ ϴ 쿡 ȣ ȮǴ ʴ´١ ǽϿ ޱ Ͽ ƴ϶ (good faith) 쿡 Ͽ Ǿ Ѵٴ ִ. 2001. 8. 16. 991990 ǰ; 2003. 12. 23. 200223632 ǰ.
׷ ̿ ޸ ࿡ Կ ٸ ƴ϶ ϴ 1  ʴ ϹǷ, ȣޱ ̶ ϴ ɼ ϴ ο شѴ. ǽϿ. 2006. 5. 10. 200519643 ǰ; 2008. 6. 18. 200727242 ǰ.
ǰᵵ ֱ ġ ǰ ǥϴ Ͱ ൿ μ ظ ٰŰ մ ߻ 쿡 ִ ̰, ȣޱ Ͽٰ Ͽ ޸ ƴϴ. ǽϿ ̷ Ȯϰ ִ. 2008. 7. 24. 200719539 ǰ; 2009. 7. 15. 2009331 ǰ.
̿ ǰ ޸ νû (good faith) δ ƴ϶ ϰ ִ.
    ü Ρ νû (good faith) 䱸 Ϻ ڵ ̳ Ϻ ʿ ٰ δ. ,  ű 籹 ָ Ͽ ʷ , 쿬ϰ Ȥ ڹ ׷ νû ϱ ׷ 츦 Ͽ, (good faith) ڷ Ρ(bootstrap refugee) David Martin, 'Remarks on Mass Migration of Refugees - Law and Policy', American Society of International Law Proceedings, vol. 76 (1982), p.15.  
μ 籹 ̵鿡 Ͽ ǹ ٴ ذ װ̴. ̻ȸĢ 2004/83/EC 4 3 (d)񿡼 ű û Ȱ ȯ ûڸ Ȥ ɰ ؿ ų ΰ ϱ Ͽ ׷ Ȱ ȣ û ʿ  Ȥ ֵ ٰ Ͽ Ѵٰ ϰ ִ. ̻ȸĢ 5 ü ؿ ٰŰ ִ Ư ű ־ ų̳ ǥ̳ 츦 ϸ鼭, ű û ڽ Ͽ ̷ Ȳ ϴ , ׹ Ѽ 鼭 ܼ ޱ , ȸ Ϲ ο ʱ ִٰ ϰ ִ.    
    ̷ 濡 ܱ Ȱ Ȱ ν ű 踦 ʷϴ ϰ ϴ ȣ Ѵٰ ִ. ̴ Ȥ ȣ ο޴ ڸ ̴ ̶ ִٰ ִ. ̹ ȣ 信 ִ ̵ νû ϴ ִ ̴. ܱ ġȰ ȹϴ ϴٸ, ̷ ϰ ̶ ȣ ϴ ִ. Vigdis Vevstad, Refugee Protection: A European Challenge(Tano Aschehoug, 1998), p.53.
      
    켱, ΰ ⺻ Ǹ ǥ , , ׸ ΰݱ ܽϴ ش ض ְ ̷ Ȥ νûڵ ǥ չ 縦 ش ϴ ҷ ڸű ִ. James C. Hathaway, The Law of Refugee Status(LexisNexis, 1991), p.37.
ٵ δ ǿ νûڰ شǴ° Ͽ ǴܵǾϰ νû ̳ ź, ׸ νûڰ ű 쿡 Ǵ ű 籹 µ Ǵ ֿ ӿ ұϰ µ ̷ ⺻ Ǵ ǻ Ͽ Դ. Ϲ ǹ̿ ü (good faith) ִ ٰŸ ã . Guy S. Goodwin-Gill, 'Domain v. Secretary of State for the Home Department - Comment: Refugee Status and 'Good Faith'', International Journal of Refugee Law, vol. 12, no. 4 (2001), pp.670-671.    
𿡼 ׸ ̰ ǥϿ Ͽ νûڸ ϴ Ͽϰ ִٰ . Vigdis Vevstad, Refugee Protection: A European Challenge(Tano Aschehoug, 1998), p.54.

    Ӹ ƴ϶ δ (good faith) ̸ܱ Ϲ ȹ ִٴ ϰ , ̴ ǿ ϴ (good faith) νûڳ ġȰ νûڵ ᱹ Ϲ ڽ ִ ٴ ܸϴ ̴. Guy S. Goodwin-Gill and Jane McAdam, The Refugee in International Law, 3rd Ed.(Oxford, 2007), pp.66-67; James C. Hathaway, The Law of Refugee Status(LexisNexis, 1991), p.38.
ޱ ġȰ 쿡 ̸ νû 籹 ָϰ ȴٸ ûڴ ȴٰ ƾ Ѵ. James C. Hathaway, The Law of Refugee Status(LexisNexis, 1991), p.39.
׷ ٵ ̷ νûڴ ߱ Ͽ ű θ ϰ ġ Ȱ ϴ ô ִ ִٴ ⺻ ϰ ִ ƴѰ ϴ DZ Ѵ.  
    αⱸ ڽ ʷ , ŷڼ Ա Ӽ ϰų (good faith) 䱸ϴ Ϻ , ɼ, ɰ Ǿ ϰ ִ. UNHCR(April 2001), supra note 22, para. 34.

    ȣ Mohammed v. Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs Mohammed v. Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs, [1999] FCA 868.
׻ ִ ׸ ٰŰ ִ Ǿ ϴ ̰, ű ɰ ظ ʷϴ ظ ڹ ൿ ʷϿٰ Ͽ ٰ ǽ ִ. ׷, 2001 ̹ι νû ȣ Ȱ νû ȭϱ 쿡 ̸ Ǿ ǡ ǻ ԵǾ.  
̹αĢ ǡ ü Ρ ϰ ְ, ٸ νû Ȱ Ȥ ȯ ų̳ ǥϰ ϴ ȮεǴ 쿡    Ư(in particular) ׷ϴٴ ܼ ް ̹Ƿ, Immigration Rules para. 333P.
UNHCR 94 100 Ͽ ü Ρ Ϲ ȴ. UK Border Agency of the Home Office, Considering the Asylum Claim(24 April 2009), pp.12-13.
http://www.ukba.homeoffice.gov.uk/sitecontent/documents/policyandlaw/asylumprocessguidance/consideringanddecidingtheclaim/guidance/consideringtheasylumclaim.pdf?view=Binary, 2009. 5.31. 湮
׼ҹ M v. Secretary of State for the Home Departmentǿ νûڰ ۵ǰ ٰ ȣ û 쿡 ó̳ ź ĥ ִٴ ϰ ̿ ٷ νûڸ ȣκ ų ִ ٰŰ ٰ ǽϸ鼭 ܴ ࿡ Ǿ Ͽ. M v. Secretary of State for the Home Department, [1996] 1 WLR 507.
Danian v. Secretary of State for the Home Departmentǿ Ͽ ظ ִٴ ٰŰ ִ ִٰ ִ ûڴ ׷ ߱ ǿ ΰ ϰ, ȿ ִ. Danian v. Secretary of State for the Home Department, [2000] Imm. A.R. 96, EWCA.
ǽϿ ǡ и Ͽ.
     ü Ǵ 캸 ۶󵥽 ظ ѹα Ա ƴ϶ , ۶󵥽 ظ Ա ٸ ܸε Բ JPNK Ͽ ۶󵥽 ημ ѱ繫 ϰ ۶󵥽 ܸε鿡 ġ ź ȸ ˷, ġ ǰ Ͽ ٸ ܸε , 2005. 8. 18. 200440051 ǰ.
ѹα ԱϿ νûϷκ óϱ NLD-LA ѱ ȸ ̾Ḷ ּ¿ ġ ź ȸ ˸, ̾Ḷ տ ν Ȱ ̾Ḷ Կϰ, ġ Ȱ Բ Ͽ ѱ ȸ 21 8 Ǿ, ̾Ḷ ΰ NLD ڻӸ ƴ϶ Ϲ ġ Ͽ ִ , 2006. 2. 3. 200520993 ǰ.
߱η ѱ ημ ѱδ 6.4 õȹ ȸ ϴ Ȱ Ͽ , Ź̳ ͳݰ˻ Ͽ Ȱ ϰ ν ִ 쿡 Ͽ νû Ͽ. 2007. 10. 4. 200637370 ǰ.
׷ ѱ Ϲ Ȱ Ȱ Ź , Ȱ 6.4 õȹ ȸ, ͳ ߱ ȭ  ܿ ٸ Ȱ νû ߱ ûε Ȱ ָ񰡴ɼ ûε ߱ ο ٸ зµ ʾǷ νû źóп Ͽ ϴٰ ǴϿ. 2006. 12. 12. 200613442 ǰ.

     ɿ ̾Ḷֵ ѱ ȸμ ѹα Ȱ Ϳ ̾Ḷ ηκ Ȱ ľǵǾ ɼ , ̹ ΰ ϰų ֱ ġ ǰ ǥϴ ڽ ൿ μ ѹα ü Ǿ. ǽϿ ű 籹 ָ ɼ Ǵ Ϻ Ƿʴ ü Ρû θ ǴԿ ־ '(good faith) ǻ ϴ ̱⵵ Ѵ. ü Ρ ٽ Ǵܱ ű 籹 ָ ɼ ϱ ٴ '(good faith) ǻ ֵ Ǵܱ Ǵϴ Ƿʵ Ѵ. û ''(good faith) û ǵ ǻ簡 ƴ ذɼ ǥ Ͽ Կ ұϰ, Ϻ Ƿʴ ġ Ȱ Ͽ OO ", "Ƿ 巯 ٰŷ Ȱ̾ ߴ", "ҹüڷμ ȯǰ Ǿ ̻ Ȱ ̶ νû ", νû "Ű " ѵ ұ Ǵ û ǡ(good faith) ο Ǵ ٽ ϰ ְ, 2007. 9. 4. 20071912 ǰ; 2006. 11. 28. 200623531 ǰ .
ɿ û Ȱ ϱ ̶͡ Ǵ ̡ ٰ ǽϿ. 2008. 7. 24. 200719539 ǰ.
ó νû Ա, δü  Ե Ȥ νû  ָϴ ذɼ θ Ǵ 䱸ϴ ࿡ ִ. 弭, ǰ ⡻(κȣƮũ , 2007. 9), p.7.


3 dz(Internal Flight Alternative) The Michigan Guidelines on the Internal Protection Alternative dz Ȥ ȡ(Internal flight or relocation alternative)ٴ ' ȣ '(Internal protection alternative) Ȯ ǥ ϰ ִ. First Colloquium on Challenges in International Refugee Law, The Michigan Guidelines on the Internal Protection Alternative (April 1999), .
ٰŰ ִ ɼ

     ű Ϻ ȿ ȣ ִٸ ״ 迡 óִٰ µ James C. Hathaway, The Law of Refugee Status(LexisNexis, 1991), p.133.
̴ ȣ ܿ ٸ ̵鿡 ־ ̱ ̴. Andrew E. Shacknove, 'Who Is a Refugee?' Ethics, vol. 95, no. 2, (1985), p.277.
ݸ鿡 ű ü 信 䱸ϰų ̸ ϰ ʴ. UNHCR 91: Reinhard Marx, 'The Criteria for Applying the "Internal Flight Alternative" Test in National Refugee Status Determination Procedures', International Journal of Refugee Law, vol. 14, no. 2 (2002), p.179.  
1969⿡ äõ ī ī ι Ư īձⱸ 1 2 ű Ǵ Ϻ Ǵ οǡ Ȳ ν ǻ dz Ȥ ȡ ǻ ϰ ִ.
ü ģ ش ϴ Ư Ҷ , ؿ ٰŰ ִ ٴ û 忡 ü κμ ٷ Ѵ. Deborah E. Anker, Law of Asylum in the United States, 3rd Ed. (Refugee Law Conter, Inc., 1999), p.56; Reinhard Marx, 'The Criteria for Applying the "Internal Flight Alternative" Test in National Refugee Status Determination Procedures', International Journal of Refugee Law, vol. 14, no. 2 (2002), p.180.  
dz Ȥ ȡ(Internal flight or relocation alternative) Ǵ û ̾ , νûڰ νû ϱ ȣ ִ Ұ ȮεǾ Ѵٴ ̴. Michael Walton, 'Backgrond Paper on The Refugee Definition', Searching for Solutions: Background Papers for the Executive Committee of the UNHCR Programme - Annual Meeting 2002 (UNHCR, 2002), p.100.
dz Ȥ ȡ Ư Ҹ ǹϴµ, ̰ ؿ ٰŰ ִ , Ư Ȳ Ͽ Ͽ ִ ո ǹѴ. ij ׼ҹ Thirunavukkarasu v. Canada Ƿ, ȣ ׼ҹ SZAZX v Milister for Immigration Ƿ ̸ Ȯϰ ִ.

̶ ǿ "" ̰  ƴϴ. ִٰ Ǵ Ͽ ü ߴ ɼ Ѵٴ ɼ ԰Ͽ å ûڿ ִ. ߷п ̰ų ̷ ̾ ȴ. װ ݵ ̰, ִ ̾ Ѵ. Ҵ ûڿ Ͽ Ѵ. ̷ ո̶ ϴ ̰ ûڴ ƴϴ. Thirunavukkarasu v. Canada (Minister of Employment and Immigration) [1994] 1 FC 589 (CA), 10 November 1993 (Canada Federal Court of Appeal).
  

û װ Ҵ ƴ 迡 ٰŰ ִ°̴. ϰ ٵǾ ȴ. ûڰ ٸ ־, ׸ װ ո Ͽ ʿ䰡 ִ. ȣ ո ٰ ʴٸ ؿ ٰŰ ִ ̴. SZAZX v Milister for Immigration [2004] FMCA 393 (16 July 2004).


     ո , ǻ ڴ ûڰ ϴ "ϰ Ȥ" ΰ غƾ Ѵ. Karanakaran v. Secretary of State for the Home Department [2000] EWCA Civ. 11, 25 January 2000 (England and Wales Court of Appeal).  
, dz Ȥ ȡ ̰, డϰ, ϰ ؾ Ѵ. Niraj Nathawani, Rethinking Refugee Law (Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 2003), p.100.
ٰɼ ǹ ִ ȣ Ǿ ϴ ̴. , Ȥ ٸ ٸ ̵ ϴ , ȣ ù, ġ ȸ α ⺻ ؿ ġ ϴ , Ÿ ٸ ̶ ȯ ʰų Ұ  νɻ翡 dz Ȥ ȡ Ǿ ȴ. James C. Hathaway, The Law of Refugee Status(LexisNexis, 1991), p.134.
ȣ ׼ҹ Al-Amidi v MINA ǿ ո õ ҷ û , , ù ġ Ǹ Թ, ǰ ִ. Al-Amidi v MINA (2000) FCA (4 August 2000).
dz Ȥ ȡ Ǵ 信 ϰ ̷ ʾҰ پϰ ϰ ִ. dz Ȥ ȡ ι Ģ̰ų ɻ ƴ κ 򰡵 ִ. UNHCR, Guidelines on International Protection: "Internal Flight or Relocation Alternative" within the Context of Article 1A(2) of the 1951 Convention and/or 1967 Protocol relating to the Status of Refugees, HCR/GIP/03/04(23 July 2003), pp.2-3.

     ȣ(Internal Protection Alternative) ǽ ٰŷ ٰŰ ִ 縦 ϰ ִ. ؼ ī϶(Kailali) ȸ(Nepali Congress Party: NCP) ִ(Democratic Party Cadre) Ҽ ȰϿ ûڿ Ͽ ī϶ ̽Ʈ ݱκ ظ ־ٰ ϴ, ̽Ʈ ƴ īƮη ̻ Ŀ ׷ ̴ ûڰ ̽Ʈ ݱκ ظ ٰŰ ִ ִٰ ϱ ƴٰ ǴϿ, 2008. 4. 11. 200731836 ǰ.
̾Ḷ ģ νûڿ Ͽ ٸ dzó ִٴ ո ִ 쿡 ƴϴ¹ 쿡 ذ Ͼ (ε)  ǻ ε ٸ Ȱ ̴ ûڰ Ҽ ̶ ź, ⵶ , ġ ǰ Ͽ ظ ִٴ ٰŰ ִ ִ ο شѴٰ ٰ ǽϿ. 2008. 5. 14. 200732105 ǰ.
̱ νûڰ ٸ ν ظ ִٸ ûڴ ؿ ٰŰ ִ ʴ´. ϰ ִ. 8 C.F.R. 208.13(b)(2).

    ׷ Ư ʿ õ dzó Ȥ ִ Կ ־ ߱ϰ ٰκ dz ȲӸ ƴ϶ õ 巡 ǹ ִ ִ Ͽ ð ϴ ʿϴ. Januzi v. Secretary of State for the Home Department; Hamid v. Secretary of State for the Home Department; Gaafar v. Secretary of State for the Home Department; Mohammed v. Secretary of State for the Home Department, [2006] UKHL 5, 15 February 2006 (UK House of Lords); Secretary of State for the Home Department (Appellant) v. AH (Sudan) and Others (FC) (Respondents) [2007] UKHL 49, 14 November 2007.
Ƿʴ ̽Ʈ ݱ κ ϰ ־ ƴϴ Ȱ ؿԴٴ ǹ̿ dz Ȥ ȡ Ͽٰ ƴ. Ƿʴ ûڰ δ εó ༼ϸ ȰϿ ̾Ḷ̰ ε ű̶ ƴٴ ִٰ Ǵܵȴ. ij ׼ҹ Hurt v. Minister of Manpower and Immigration ǿ νû ֱ ƴ 迡 򰡵Ǿ ϰ ֱ ȣɼ δ 迡 ΰ Ȯ Ŀ ɼ ǹ̸ ̶ ǽ ִ. [1978] 2 F.C. 340 (C.A.).

   ̷ Ƿʿʹ ޸ ⵶ Ư ź ȿ ȮǾ ִ ̾ Ϲ ǽ ɡϴ ϴ, ƴ϶ ̶ ġ ְ, ؿ Ͽ ǽ ϴ, ǽν κ  ִٰ ϱ ƴٰ ǽ ִ. 2008. 5. 2. 200724746 ǰ.
׷ Ǵ 浹 ϱ Ͽ ٸ ǽ , ǽ ۡ۸ ̽ κ ظ ǰ Ͽ. 2008. 11. 25. 200813776 ǰ.

     ̾Ḷ ģ 2 ǰῡ 1 Ǵ UNHCR 91 ȿ dz Ȥ ȡ 縦 ϰ ִ. ظ ݵ ü Ȯ ʿ Ǵ Ȳ ߴ ҿ , Ư Ǵ ܿ ش Ϻ , ܼ ٸ dzó ִٴ Ǹδ װ ׷ ϴ ո 쿡 ʴ ̹Ƿ( 91 ), ε ĶĿŸ üϿ Դٴ μ ٴ ̴. 2009. 1. 8. 200813608 ǰ.
        
     ̻ȸĢ 2004/83/EC 8 ո 롱 ϸ鼭 ϹݻȲ û Ȳ Ͽ ϰ ű ư ƴ϶ ϰ ִ. The Michigan Guidelines on the Internal Protection Alternative First Colloquium on Challenges in International Refugee Law, The Michigan Guidelines on the Internal Protection Alternative (April 1999); Reinhard Marx, 'The Criteria for Applying the "Internal Flight Alternative" Test in National Refugee Status Determination Procedures', International Journal of Refugee Law, vol. 14, no. 2 (2002), pp.184-185.  
ȣ , (1) 迡 ص, (2) Ȥ ؿ ϴ ߰ , (3) ּ ȣ ְ, ̷ Ǹ ո ɻ ʿϴٰ ϰ ִ.  
     αⱸ Ʒ dz Ȥ ȡ ϱ ü ϰ ִµ dz Ȥ ȡ Ǵ ȿ ̷ ü ؿ ԰ ɻ縦 ϰ ִ ǹ̴.

I. м(Relevance Analysis)
a) ִ ο , ϰ, ׸ ٰѰ?: ̷ ϳ Ѵٸ ̴.
b) ü ΰ?: ü ȰѴٰ ȴ. ׵ ڶ, dz Ȥ Ģ ʴ ȴ.
c) ü 񱹰 üΰ?: 񱹰 ü õ ûڸ Ѵٸ dz Ȥ . ̷ ڰ ûڸ ɼ ִ, ׸ طκ ȣ ϰ ȴ.
d) ֿ Ͽ ûڰ ̳ ٸ ɰ ؿ ΰ?: ̰ Ȥ  ο Ǵ ٸ ɰ ظ Ѵ.          

II. ո м(Reasonableness Analysis)
ƶ, ûڰ 뿡 ʰ ִ°?: ׷ ʴٸ װ ϴ ո ʴ. UNHCR, Guidelines on International Protection: "Internal Flight or Relocation Alternative" within the Context of Article 1A(2) of the 1951 Convention and/or 1967 Protocol relating to the Status of Refugees, HCR/GIP/03/04(23 July 2003), p.3.

                  
4   

    ظ Դٴ νûڵ 忡 ظ ʾҴٴ ٰŰ ִ ϴ ߿ ٰ ϳ ǽϰ ִ. ׷ ϰ ϴ Ҵ 簡 ϴ ұ Ұ ̴.  1951 ࿡ ŵ Ͽ ̹ ڰ Ǿٸ, װ ظ ִ ٰŰ ִ ִ. ׷ ظ ̵Ӹ ƴ϶ Ű Ȳ ϰ ϴ ̵ õȴ. UNHCR 45; Dirk Vanheule, 'United States', Carlier, Jean-Yves, Vanheule, Dirk, Hullmann, Klaus and Galiano, Calos Pena  (eds.), Who Is a Refugee? A Comparative Case Law Study (Kluwer, 1997), p.619.
ش ൵ 巡 κ ȣ ϰ ظ ʴ´. Deborah E. Anker, Law of Asylum in the United States, 3rd Ed. (Refugee Law Conter, Inc., 1999), p.32.  
ݸ鿡 Ű ϰ Ǹ, װ ٷ νûڰ ǹϴ ƴ, װ νû ȯ ִ Ͽ ǽ Ȯ ǥ ִ. 巡 ɼ ϰ ߿ Ȳ ȭ , Ư Ͽ 巡 ؿ ִ ̴. James C. Hathaway, The Law of Refugee Status(LexisNexis, 1991), pp.87-88; John Vrachnas, Kim Boyd, Mirko Bagaric and Penny Dimopoulos, Migration and Refugee Law: Principles and Practice in Australia, 2nd Ed. (Cambridge University Press, 2008), pp.255-257.

    ij ̹׼ҹ Guillermo Lautaro Diaz Fuentes Guillermo Lautaro Diaz Fuentes, (1974), 9 I.A.C. 341, per J. P. Houle;
ذ ̹ Ͽٴ ǿ ʴ´ٴ и Ͽ, ׼ҹ 簡 κ ٰŷ ۿϴ Ϳ Ͽ и ϰ ִ.

(̹׼)ȸ ûڿ Ͼ ̡ü ʾұ ؿ ̸ ʴٰ δ. ̷ν ȸ¡ Ͼ ü ° ִ Ӹ ƴ϶, , 1973 1974 ϵ Բ, ظ ִٴ ٰŰ ִ ٰŰ ִ ϴ Ͽ. Alfredo Manuel Oyarzo Marchant v. Minister of Employment and Immigration, [1982] 2 F.C. 781, per Thurlow C.J.


ij ׼ҹ ȮϿµ, Francisco Humberto Gonzalez Galindo ǿ ִ Ƿ Ÿ ʾҴٴ ̹׼ȸ ôϸ鼭 Ŵ νû ġȰ ߴٴ ȸ ҽĽŰ ִ Ű ִٰ ǽϿ. Francisco Humberto Gonzalez Galindo, [1981] 2 F.C. 781 (C.A.).

    ̱ ظ ϳ ϰ ִ.
← End



[Title]
Ƿ ؼ - ٰŰ ִ ؼ 2009. 9. 14. 溯ȣȸ μҼ ̳ ڷ Ƿʺм: ߽Ρ ․ .



  8 →   I. νû ۼ  
  7 →   üڰ û  
  6 →   I. ûڿ Ȱ㰡  
  5 →   û  
  4 →   ܱȯġ Ͽ Ŵ  
  1 →   ҹüܱ Ȯ üڰ û․  

  ← Previous [1][2][3][4][5] 6
     
       

[Category]


  • retainer fee
  • consulting fee
  • Resume of Attorney LEE
  • REFUGE, ASYLUM IN KOREA
  • Self Advocacy Statement for case
  • VISA IN KOREA
  • REMOVAL, DEPORTATION
  • B VISA
  • C VISA
  • D VISA
  • E VISA
  • F VISA
  • G VISA
  • H VISA
  • STAY, EXTENSION, CHANGE OF STATUS
  • PASSPORT OF KOREA
  • ADMISSION INSPECTION INTO KOREA
  • IMMIGRATION LAW OF KOREA
  • INVESTMENT IN KOREA
  • EMPLOYMENT IN KOREA
  • NATURALIZATION IN KOREA
  • MARRIAGE IN KOREA
  • 뿪(translation, interpretation)
  • china visa
  • Death of Aliens, Estate, Proof of Death

Copyright 1997-2024 TAX & LAW (ݰ )
site ϴ ƴϸ, ̰ "" Ƿ(¶ ƴ϶ å Ⱓ Ƿ) Ǹ մϴ.
, Ƿʿ Ȥö ִٸ, װ ƴϸ, Ͽ ̰ų ̶ Ͻñ ٶϴ.
׷ ұϰ ̸ ̶ ϽŴٸ, ϴ Ʈ ƴ϶ ׷ Ͽ (å Ⱓ Ƿ) Ƿ Ͻʽÿ. 繫ǿ Ͻ κ ƴմϴ.

FEE
Ұ
| λ

|
TAX
|

뵿
|

| Ư
PAT
ǥ
|

Ѽ
|
ART
|

|

| USA
̹
VISA
| ȥ

| Foreign
Clients
| |